through one eyebrow, small and white, that gave her whole face a look of having been interrupted midargument by life and finished the argument anyway. Her hair was braided with a strip of red cloth. Her
hands were stained green to the wrist from her medicines.
"You are the man who refused me in my father's lodge," she said.
The corral, the morning, the horse between them - Caleb felt all of it narrow to the sentence.
"I refused the way it was offered," he said. "There's a difference."
"Is there?" She stood, brushing dirt from her dress with hard, economical slaps. "My brother carried
your speech to me word for word, as he was told. It was a fine speech. Kito does not admire it, but Kito
could not find a crack in it either, and that is eating him worse than the speech. So I am here to find the
crack, reader of papers. Every man who makes a speech about a woman's freedom wants something for
making it. What do you want?"
"To be judged true," Caleb said. "Same as I'd ask of any camp that might have to trust me. And a
horse that walks again. That one's nearer my heart at the moment, if you'll forgive it."
"You are forgiven. It is the correct order. A man who puts me above his horse on one day's knowing is
either lying or light-headed." She folded her arms. "Then hear my terms for your judging, since
everyone in this valley is laying terms on tables like cards. You will work while you are watched - no
guest's idleness; idle men are only ever judged for their worst hour. You will not speak to me of the
marriage. Not once. If you wish me to know a thing about you, let me find it with my eyes, in your work
and your temper and how you are with the horse when he is frightened in the night. Speeches I have had.
My father made them. Taho's mother made them. The priest of paper in Helena makes them in letters. I
am done being talked at by men arranging my life."
"Taho," Caleb said carefully. "Your first - the one who died."
"Ask the camp about my graves," she said, and the temperature of her voice dropped ten degrees.
"They will enjoy telling you. It is their favorite story that is not theirs." She gathered her medicine bag
and went over the rails in one motion, light as a boy. At the top she paused. "The poultice changes at
sundown. You will do it. I will watch your hands and correct them once. If you argue with the
correction, I will know everything about you that matters and we can both stop wasting the autumn."
Then she was gone, and Caleb stood in the pen with his hand still on Rusty's neck, and the horse turned
his head and looked at him with one dark eye in a way that seemed, somehow, to be on her side.
"Six weeks, she said," Caleb told him. "For the leg. Forty dollars a month and a cot, gone. And I've
got to be judged without talking, by a woman who can smell a lie through a poultice." He scratched the
sorrel's forehead. "Partner, I believe we've ridden into the only valley in Montana where falling in a hole
was the easy part."
He changed the poultice at sundown, and she watched from the rails with her chin on her folded
arms, and corrected him once - "Tighter at the bottom. The swelling walks down, not up. You are
dressing it like a man covering a thing he is sorry for; dress it like a thing you expect to heal." - and did
not correct him again. When he had done, she came down into the pen and put her own hand flat over
his work for the count of ten, and nodded once, and it felt absurdly like passing an examination he had
once failed at West Point and at every schoolhouse since.
"You have good hands," she said, grudging as a tax collector. "Someone taught you before you
learned to be stubborn."
"My father. With horses, and my mother with books, and between them they made a man fit for
neither a ranch nor a schoolroom, so I have been a tourist in both all my life."
"Hm." She untied the apron of medicines and folded it. The light was going copper over the valley
and the small fires were coming up one by one along the crescent of lodges, and somebody not far away
was singing a child down to sleep in a language Caleb did not need translated to understand. "Tomas
will find you a place to sleep. Tomorrow you mend fence with the horse boys, I am told. Kito's
instruction. He hopes the work will disgust you."
"Will it?"
"Fence work disgusts every man. The question is only what he sings while he does it." She climbed the
rails. "Sleep well, reader of papers. You are watched by forty rifles and one grandmother, and the
grandmother is the one to fear. She has already decided about you. Grandmothers in this camp decide
first and arrange the evidence after."
And she left him there in the blue dusk, beside his healing horse, with the whole unchosen shape of
the thing ahead of him - the work, the watching, the deadline of snow, and a woman who had forbidden
him the one subject he had crossed a valley to settle, and who had nonetheless, with her hand flat over
his bandaging for the count of ten, begun the judging.
Chapter 5: Under Watch
They gave him a bed in the lodge of Tomas's widowed aunt, a lean-to place by the door where the drafts