in the south, in the bad years, that he dreams about in this lodge with the door tied shut. Kito has a name
he does not say. I have two graves I did not dig and cannot undig." She turned the spade over in her
hands. "The question was never whether your hands are clean. No grown person's are. The question is
what you did with the dirt afterward. You carried yours seven years and let it cost you your trade and
your pride. That is - " she searched for the word with the air of a woman who admits a thing once and
expects it filed correctly, " - that is evidence. In my court."
She picked up the bucket. "Come. The ditch will run clear tonight, and tomorrow my father wants
your reading again. There is a paper he has not shown you. I found it in his things when I changed his
bedding, and he does not know I know, and that, reader of papers, frightens me more than everything the
camp whispers, all of it together."
They worked down the ditch line in the long afternoon light, clearing the last two intakes, and it was
on the walk back, with the spades on their shoulders and the water running clear and musical behind
them in the channel, that she told him about the teacher.
"Her name was Ruth Adler. She was taken from a wagon train on the Platte when she was nineteen, by a
raiding party of the people we used to be, in the years before my father forbade the taking of captives
and made it hold. She was ransomed twice and refused both ransoms - the second time she stood in the
council and said she had buried a husband and a child of fever on that train and there was nothing east of
the Missouri that was hers anymore, and she would stay, if the people would have a woman whose only
wealth was letters. They had her. For twenty-two years they had her." Tavira's step did not change. "She
taught me English the way you teach a person to swim - by expecting it. Reading, writing, figures. She
taught me that a paper is a weapon that anyone may pick up, and that the people who write the papers
count on the rest of the world leaving the weapon lying in the dirt. She died in the winter of the deep
snow, of the cough, the same cough my father has now, and I was fifteen and held her head. The last
thing she made me promise was the school. Not a grave tended. Not a song. A school."
"That's why the letters in the dirt," Caleb said.
"That is why everything," Tavira said. "You asked at the spring why I showed you the water. I will
give you the rest of the answer, since we are telling whole truths today and it has put me in the habit. I
showed you because Ruth used to say: judge a man's errand by what he does at the water. Men are
honest at water. It is the oldest law in this country, older than my people and yours together." She
glanced at him, quick and dry. "You cleaned the headgate like a man who expected to drink from it in
ten years. I noticed. File it where you like."
Below them the valley was going gold and violet, lodge smoke rising into still air, and Caleb walked the
last of the path in a silence he did not want to spend on anything cheap. A woman had crossed an ocean
of grief to leave a school in a hidden valley, and a girl had kept the promise for eleven years with a stick
in the dirt, and now a railroad was coming with a paper that called the valley empty, and all of it - the
spring, the school, the paper, the dead - was converging on a council fire that had not yet been lit, and on
the one decision that nobody in the valley, it seemed, was willing to make for the woman it belonged to.
Except that she was going to make it herself. He held onto that all the way down, like a rail in the
dark.
Chapter 8: The Brass Marker
The paper Tavira had found was produced in the chief's lodge that night, and Dasay did not pretend
surprise when she laid it on the boards herself, between the fire and her father's hands, and stepped back
to the wall to stand with her brother.
"You go through my bedding now," Dasay said mildly.
"I change your bedding because you cough blood into it and hide the cloths under the floor," Tavira
said, and the lodge went very still, and Caleb understood that this, too, was a confession that had been
waiting for its hour. "The whole camp knows, Father. Only you are still performing not knowing. Read
the white man's paper, and then tell us all of it. He cannot judge, and I cannot choose, with half the
board covered."
Dasay looked at the paper a long time. Then he nodded, once, at Caleb, with the air of a man handing
over the last of his weapons.
It was a copy of a petition, and this one Caleb read with his hands not quite steady. Petitioner: Marcus
Vail, agent, Continental and Northern Railroad Company. Subject: the removal of sundry hostile Indians
unlawfully occupying surveyed public lands in the valley described. It recited a list of offenses the way
a man deals cards he has marked: stock stolen, a survey crew threatened, a settler's cabin burned the
previous winter on the freight road. Caleb had ridden that road in the summer. The cabin had burned,