did.
"My instructions," Pike said at last, slowly, "authorize survey of unoccupied public land, and forbid
entry upon lands under cultivation or dwelling until the question of occupancy is settled at the hearing."
He swallowed. "There is to be a hearing. At Fort Shaw. Nine days from now, before the post commander
and the territorial land registrar, on the railroad's petition and — and any counter-testimony." He looked
downslope then, at the scatter of watch fires in the valley he had been sent to erase, and his book came
down from his chest by an inch, the way a shield comes down when the man behind it has started doing
sums of his own. "Vail told me there would be no counter-testimony. He told me the escort was a
formality and the valley a rumor."
"The valley," Kito said, in his careful, unhurried English, speaking for the first time, "is standing on
its rim with empty hands, telling your men good evening. Go down and look at it in the morning,
surveyor, with no chain. Count our houses. Then write what you see in your book, and we will see
which of your pages the fort believes."
Pike withdrew above the rim before midnight, every torch, every stake pulled up out of the throat
gravel by his own chainmen under Benno's solemn supervision, and the last thing he did before he
turned for his camp was a thing no one had asked of him: he opened the survey book on a flat rock, in
the lantern light, where Tavira could see the page, and under the line about the shot fired on a federal
survey he wrote, in his neat and ruinous hand, Correction: one lantern, no man struck. Occupied valley.
Entry deferred to hearing. And he initialed it, and Caleb understood that Marcus Vail had just lost his
first soldier, and did not know it yet, and that somewhere under the rim a boy of seventeen had bought
that loss with a single bullet aimed, deliberately, at the light instead of the man.
Chapter 12: The Answer Given Freely
Pike came down at daylight with no chain, as invited, two chainmen at a respectful distance and his hat
in his hands by the time he reached the corn. Tavira walked him through the valley like a bailiff through
evidence: forty-one dwellings in their crescent, the ditch and its headgate, the corn and squash plots in
their squared order, the root cellars, the forge, the cache caves, the graves in their fenced ground above
the creek where the headboards, some of them, had letters cut by her own hand. She showed him the
school that did not yet have a roof — a circle of benches under the big cottonwood, a board of smoothed
pine, thirty-one children who stood when he passed and recited, in English, because their teacher had
decided the enemy's language should be disarmed in their mouths early, the names of the months and the
multiplication of sevens.
Pike wrote it all down. Whatever else Marcus Vail had bought in the world, he had not bought this
man's book, and the book was filling with a valley.
At noon he rode out of the throat with his party in good order and a face like a man carrying
something breakable a long way. The escort, he told Caleb at the gate, would not move until the hearing;
Doyle had orders to hold at the fort until the registrar sat, and Vail was at Fort Shaw already, in the
sutler's best room, wearing out the commander's floor with another man's patience. Nine days. The
valley went back to its work with the held-breath feeling of a reprieve, which is a debt wearing a cleaner
shirt.
The council fire was lit again that evening, early, in full light of a low red sun, because Dasay said the
interrupted business of a people should not have to wait for dark twice.
There were no braziers of feast waiting this time. There was only the fire, and the rings, and the old
chief standing with his son's arm under his and his empty hands held out again in that terrible, patient
courtesy, and his daughter stepping into the center in her ordinary dress, with her hair bound in the red
cloth, exactly as she had the night before — because she had chosen, she told Caleb afterward, to make
it clear to the record that nothing about her had been decorated into compliance.
"I was promised twice by arrangement," she said, in her own tongue, and then again in English,
because she wanted the stranger's half of the record kept by his own ears. "Both times I was told it was
for the people's good, and both times the ground took the man, and the people, who are kind, called it a
curse because a curse is easier to carry than the truth, which is that men die of fevers and horses fall, in a
hard country, whether a woman has been promised or not. I have lived six years under a name I did not
make. Tonight I am making my own."
She looked at her father. "You did one thing in this that I will honor all my life. When it came to it,
you opened your hands and they were empty. No father in this camp's memory has done that. I release
you from the asking, and I take the choosing where it has always belonged." Then she looked around the
rings, face by face, the way she had the night before, taking attendance on her own life. "And I choose.
Freely, and in front of everyone, so that no clerk in Helena and no whisper in this camp can ever call it