watch heavy in his vest, watched her look around the circle - slowly, face by face, at the people she had
healed and taught and buried kin for, at her brother with his jaw set like a trap, at her grandmother who
was, disgracefully, already smiling - and he understood that she was not gathering courage. She was
taking attendance. Whatever she said, she wanted the saying of it witnessed by the whole of her life.
Then she looked at him, across the fire, and he saw her draw the breath that carried the first word of
her answer up out of her chest and into her mouth.
On the north rim, a mile above the valley's throat, a light bloomed where no light had any business
being.
Then another. Then a line of them, torches, six, eight, a dozen, kindling one from the next along the
rim trail in the dark, and moving - moving the way a line of men moves when it is coming down out of
high country in no particular hurry, because it believes the country below it is already its own.
The council fire did not so much break as stand up. Kito was at the rim of the light with his rifle in
his hands before the second torch caught, and Dasay's voice, sudden and young and absolute, was giving
orders in two languages, and Tomas had Caleb by the sleeve - not restraining him, pulling him toward,
the way you pull a man into his own place in a line that is forming.
Down the throat of the valley, very far away and horribly clear in the cold air, a single rifle shot
cracked and rolled among the rocks, and the torches on the rim stopped moving, all together, the way a
held breath stops.
Tavira stood alone in the center of the ring with the fire at her back and her answer still in her mouth,
and looked up at the line of lights on her valley's edge, and then - while the whole camp watched, and
the night braced itself - she began, deliberately, to speak.
Chapter 11: Torches on the North Rim
"No man lights a torch on my father's rim," Tavira said, "and hurries my mouth."
She said it clearly, in English first and then in her own tongue, so that both halves of the night would
have it word for word, and the camp heard her, and something in the hundred and forty of them settled
even as their hands tightened on their rifles. It was not the answer. It was the claiming of the answer,
which in its way was larger, because it told every soul at that fire — and every soul on the rim above, if
sound carried the way shame does — that what was coming down out of the dark would be met by a
people whose daughter had not been rattled out of her own sentence by a line of fire.
Then she turned from the fire and walked, not ran, to her father's side, and put her hand flat on his
chest the way she did when she was listening to his breath, and said something low that Caleb did not
catch. Dasay nodded. Kito was already shouting the rim watch up the ladders. And Caleb found himself
moving with Tomas's hand still clamped in his sleeve, up through the breaking rings of the council
toward the north scaffold, with the whole camp streaming into the dark in the practiced silence of people
who had rehearsed this night in their heads for eleven years.
The torches had stopped. That was the shot's doing, and on the scaffold, with the cold biting through his
good shirt, Caleb finally understood the shot. Below the rim, down at the throat where the trail pinched
between two shoulders of rock, a second and smaller party had been working in the dark with a hooded
lantern — chaining the throat, the valley's only door, while the torch line above drew every eye in camp
uphill. The shot had come from the camp's own throat outpost: Benno, seventeen and sleepless and
posted there since dusk with Dasay's second rifle, who had watched the lantern men drive their first
stake into the gravel of the pass, and had done the arithmetic of a boy who had been shamed once and
meant never to be shamed the same way twice, and had put his bullet through the lantern itself rather
than through any man carrying it.
The glass had burst in a small, bright flower of oil and flame, and the throat party had gone to ground
among the rocks, and the torch line above had frozen at the sound, because men carrying fire in the dark
know what a rifle shot does to the value of standing still in the light.
"Boy shoots like a sermon," Tomas said, arriving at the scaffold rail with his wounded side bound and
his teeth bared against the climb. "All warning. No waste."
"He shot at all," Kito said grimly, from the dark below. "Now they will say we fired on the survey.
Vail will put it in a paper before the glass is cold." He came up the ladder in three pulls and stood
looking at the torch line, and Caleb watched a war leader do the hardest thing in his profession, which is
nothing, deliberately, while it cost him. "If we ride up there now, in the dark, with rifles, whatever
happens will be the only story the fort ever hears. If we sit here, they plant their stakes on my father's
rim and photograph us with their instruments at daylight, squatting in our own valley like tenants." He
turned his head. "Reader. You have stood in their offices. Tell me what the paper wants, because the
paper is the enemy I cannot shoot."