will lift a hand to you on the way, and I will say at the council that the refusal was hers and honorable.
Either way, scout - the valley keeps its word. See that you keep yours about the fort. Papers or no
papers. Wife or no wife."
"Either way," Caleb said. "I ride, and I talk, and I sign my name to what I saw. You have it."
Kito nodded and went up the canyon path, and Caleb stood in the gathering dark with the horses
moving around him like a river finding its banks, and understood that he had been given, in the space of
an hour, the two things he had spent seven years believing were extinct in the world: a deadline, and a
reason.
Tavira walked him back from the canyon, unplanned, both of them falling in with the water carriers
on the spring path as the first stars came. For once she was not carrying anything. For once, neither was
he.
"Tomorrow I give my answer at the council fire," she said. "That is the custom. A thing of this size is
not whispered in corners. I wanted you to hear it from me in a corner first, so that the fire is only an
echo." She walked a while. "I have judged you, Caleb Rourke. I have watched your hands and your
temper and your horse in the night. I have heard your confession at my spring and I have watched you
shell beans with my grandmother, which has ended stronger men than the Army ever did. I know what
you are. I have only ever had one question left, and it was never about you."
"The promising," Caleb said.
"The promising," she agreed. "Whether I can stand up in front of my people and let a third promise be
laid on my life with my own consent in it, and not hear, in the middle of it, a fish bone and a dark road.
Whether choosing it myself takes the curse off it, or whether the curse is just - " she stopped on the path,
and the water carriers parted around them like a stream around a stone, " - whether the curse is only the
name frightened people give to the fact that the world is dangerous and I am done letting frightened
people name my life. That is not a question a day answers. But it is the question, and it is mine, and I
will answer it tomorrow in front of everyone, and whatever I say, scout, I want you to remember that the
saying of it will be the freest thing I have ever done - freer than Taho, freer than Pero, freer than my
father's lodge and his papers. If I say yes, it will not be the bargain. It will be me."
"I know," Caleb said. "That's the only yes I'd cross a valley to hear. The other kind I was offered once
already, in an office, at forty dollars a month."
She looked at him sidelong, in the starlight, and something in her face moved that he had not seen
there before - not softness, exactly, but its reconnaissance party.
"Shell your own beans tomorrow," she said. "Grandmother cheats at judging when she likes a man. I
have told her so. She laughed for an hour. It is very irritating to be raised by seers."
That night he took a watch on the north scaffold himself, because Tomas was flat on a blanket with a
hole through his ribs being picturesque about it, and because Kito, handing him up a rifle at the ladder -
Dasay's own rifle, a fact whose weight Caleb registered and did not comment on - said only: "Two
hours. Sing out at anything. Even a feeling. Especially a feeling. Feelings have outlived more scouts
than rifles have killed," and vanished into the dark like a man late for being somewhere else.
The valley at night, from above, was a different country. The fires went down one by one in their order,
like a town blowing out lamps street by street, until only the watch fires were left, hooded and small.
The creek made its sound. The spring, even at that distance, seemed to breathe a faint warmth up the
slope, a smell of stone and minerals underneath the pine smoke. Somewhere below, a horse stamped, a
child whimpered once and was sung down, and Caleb sat in the cold with a dead man's watch in his
pocket and a chief's rifle across his knees and did his arithmetic the way he had been trained: ranges,
approaches, the throat of the valley narrow enough for twenty rifles to hold against two hundred - for a
day. For three. Not for a winter, and not against an army that could simply sit on the rim and starve the
spring's ditch with a dozen men and a shovel.
That was the thing nobody at the forge or the ditch said aloud: the valley could be defended against
men, but not against paper. Paper did not need the throat. Paper sat in Helena in a warm office and grew
soldiers the way a mold grows on bread, and the soldiers would keep coming until the valley complied
or emptied. The only weapon against it was a counter-paper - testimony, witnesses, signatures, a son-inlaw's sworn statement in a fort commander's hands - and that weapon had exactly one throat of its own
to pass through, narrower than the valley's: a woman's consent, freely given, before a fire, tomorrow
night.
He thought about his mother again, and the deed-to-a-farm marriage, and understood with a
completeness that shamed his earlier understanding that his refusal in Dasay's lodge had not been
gallantry. It had been the whole strategy, arrived at by instinct: a coerced marriage would have been