The spring came out of the rock at the head of the valley, a half mile above the highest lodge, and it
came out warm. That was the first astonishment - a thread of steam in the cold morning, water running
at blood heat out of a crack in the stone into a basin somebody's grandfather had lined with fitted rock,
and from the basin into the ditch system that fed the fields, and, Tavira explained, into a second, secret
cleft behind a fall of boulders where the water ran hotter still and the camp's sick were brought in winter.
"It does not freeze," she said. "Not in the hardest winter of my grandmother's memory. That is why
we are here. Eleven years ago my father led us out of the south with the soldiers behind us and the snow
ahead, and an old woman of the Crow, who owed him a life, told him of a valley the maps leave white,
where the water is warm and the pass is one throat wide. We came in dying. The valley fed us. The
spring is the heart of this place, reader of papers. Everything else - the fields, the ditch, the cabins - is
just the body it keeps alive."
She set him to digging needles and silt out of the headgate channel and worked beside him without a
word for the better part of an hour, both of them wet to the elbow and steaming faintly in the cold like
horses. Caleb understood, about halfway through, that he was being shown the valley's most guarded
fact by the person with the most reason to guard it, and that the chore was a key turning in a lock.
"Why show me?" he asked at last.
"Because my father has already shown you our death on paper," she said. "You should also see what the
paper is about. And because - " she drove the spade in and left it standing, " - because you are to be
judged, and a man should be judged with the whole thing in front of him. If you betray us, scout, you
will betray this. Not a name on a map. This."
"Kito asked me at the creek," Caleb said, "how he can know I won't scout for the Army again, when
the Army comes. It's his question but I reckon it's yours too. I've been carrying the answer around all
week like a stone in my boot. Do you want it?"
"I am not a woman who asks twice for a thing she wants." She sat down on the basin's rim and folded
her wet arms, and waited.
So he told it, there by the warm water, whole, for the first time in seven years.
Willow Creek, 1876. A young scout, twenty-three, good at his trade and prouder of it than he had any
right to be, riding ahead of a column of the Army he believed in the way boys believe in flags. A camp
reported hostile, stolen stock, warriors gathering - all of it passed down the line to him already decided,
needing only his eyes to make it official. He had found the camp at dusk, counted lodges in the dark,
seen the horse herd and the fires and heard - he told her this part slowly - heard children, and a woman
singing one down to sleep, the same sound he had heard his first night at Kestrel Creek, and instead of
riding back and saying what he had actually found, he had said what the column wanted to hear, because
his captain was watching his face and because a scout who brings doubts instead of targets does not get
hired twice.
The column hit the camp at dawn. It was not a warriors' camp. It was a wintering village of a band
that had a paper of its own - a peace paper, signed at a fort, kept in a beaded case by its chief - and by
the time the firing stopped the paper was in the mud with the rest.
"I never fired," Caleb said. "I want that known and I don't offer it as an excuse. I did worse than fire. I
pointed. Twenty-one people, Tavira. I have their number because I made myself learn it afterward,
which is the least a man can do and also, most days, feels like the most useless thing in the world. I left
the Army in '77 and I have not scouted for a soldier since, and I will not, and that is the whole of it. Your
brother asked how he can know. He can't. You can't. There's no paper for it. There's only that I've told it
now to the one person in this valley it can hurt me most to tell."
The spring ran and steamed. A raven went over the valley with its shadow sliding across the fields
below, and neither of them watched it pass.
"You are wondering," Tavira said at last, "whether the telling helps you. In the judging."
"I'm wondering if it ends me. I'd be a fool not to."
"It would have ended you if I had dug it out of you like a bad tooth," she said. "Things confessed sit
differently from things discovered. My teacher used to say that. She was very wise about everything
except the winter that killed her." She stood and pulled the spade out of the channel and looked down
the valley at the whole of it - the crescent of lodges, the shocked corn, the scaffold with its two small
figures facing north. "Every person in that camp has a Willow Creek, scout. We are Apache in Montana.
Do you imagine we walked eleven years to get here on a road of clean hands? My father has done things