Black CEO Mistaken for Janitor — Told to Clean the Toilet, Then She Fires Everyone

Chapter 22

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Victor Anaya, interviewed in the same room three days later, arrived with a different theory and better tailoring: that he was a vendor who had staffed to the client's specification, and that if Bexley's own facilities leadership had fed his company names, his company — a services firm, not a detective agency — had processed them in good faith. Then Anaya's counsel, at a signal so small Naomi nearly missed it in the transcript, produced a binder: Groves's signed approvals, four years of them, original signatures on the monthly certification packets, each packet containing the roster page with the ghost names in plain alphabetical order. "My client," the counsel said, "kept his approvals. Vendors who are defrauded by clients' officers usually have thinner files." It was, Callahan wrote later in her report, the moment the two architects each handed her the other's half of the building.

Strasser's interview was the shortest, and in its way the saddest. The CFO did not produce theories; he produced a climate. The memo had arrived during a refinancing. Facilities variances were historically noisy. A reconciliation had been understood to be underway — he used the phrase, at last, that Naomi had saved from Calvin's office like a coin: it was being reconciled — and he could not say by whom, or since when, or what it had produced, because it had produced nothing; the phrase had been a drawer the memo was kept in. He had not taken money; Callahan's report would say so plainly, and it mattered to the exactness of the thing that she did: the CFO's culpability was not theft but custody — the memo had been his to answer, and the four years had been his to interrupt, and he had chosen, quarter after quarter, the smoothness of the numbers over the truth of them. "You understand," he said at one point, to the room, to the transcript, "the numbers were beautiful. Nobody audits beautiful."

"Nobody audits beautiful," Callahan repeated, without inflection, writing it down. "Thank you, Mr. Strasser. That will be all."

The reckoning, when it came, came the way Naomi had intended from the first morning: not as weather, but as paper, in envelopes, with names spelled right. Callahan's final report ran to two hundred and eleven pages, and its summary table — the table the board voted to release to every employee in all three sites, over the initial objection of two directors and the final unanimous vote of the whole board — said the whole thing in eleven lines. One hundred and eighteen billed positions. Eighty-three real people. Thirty-five fictitious employees, over four years. Five point four million dollars in wages billed and paid for work that was never performed by persons who never existed. One point one million in inflated equipment-lease margin. One unanswered memo. The report used the word fraud, in the forensic sense, with the care of a document that knew the difference between its findings and a court's, and it stated its referrals in the same flat tone: the file had been transmitted to the United States Attorney and to the state attorney general. What those offices would do with it was theirs. What the paper proved was Bexley's.

Walter Groves was fired for cause on a Tuesday, in the small conference room on the third floor, with Hennessy present and his own counsel on the phone, and the termination letter enumerated documents rather than adjectives: the worksheet in his hand, the approvals, the leases, the threshold amendment he had proceeded on. He was escorted to his office to collect his personal effects under supervision, and then to the elevators, by the same security officer who had walked the temp out of the building on a Thursday morning seven weeks earlier. Naomi was not present, and had arranged not to be; she had learned, from her mother among others, that the person who signs the letter does not also get to watch the door, because watching the door is a pleasure, and pleasures of that kind rot a house from the rafters. It was reported to her afterward, by Calvin, who had it from the floor, that Groves had stopped at the freight hall on his way down — against protocol, for perhaps twenty seconds — and stood looking at the roster board, which still hung there with its three colors of names, pending the reforms. Nobody recorded what he saw in it. The board was taken down that evening.

Phillip Strasser resigned during the review's fifth week, before the firings, in a letter that cited the interests of the company and his health, in that order, and the board accepted it on the condition — Dunleavy's language, and it was not negotiable — that the acceptance was without prejudice to the referrals, in which the former CFO was named, in the forensic sense, for the suppression of the variance memorandum and the quarterly certifications his office had issued over it. He left the building through the lobby at midday, carrying a banker's box, and Dottie — who was on the glass that day and saw him through twenty feet of ecclesiastical transparency — reported to the freight hall that he had looked, passing, not like a thief but like a man who had been in love with a set of numbers and had just been shown the photograph of what they actually were.

News in the same category

Black CEO Mistaken for Janitor — Told to Clean the Toilet, Then She Fires Everyone

45 Part