He paused, and the theatre was so quiet that the hum of the stage lights seemed loud.
"I am going to ask the judges to come up here," he said. "All three of them. And I am going to ask them to look at what this young lady is holding, and to tell us whether it is genuine. And then we will do what the rules of this pageant require us to do. Nothing more, and nothing less."
A sound went through the audience then — not applause, not quite, but a long exhalation, the sound of hundreds of people letting out breath they had been holding. A few people sat down, slowly, as if permission had been given. Most stayed standing. David Ellery stayed where he was, at the foot of the stage, his eyes on his daughter.
Henrietta Loomis was already on her feet. She had risen the moment Delilah was led away, and she had not sat down again. Now she came around the judges' table, moving with the unhurried dignity of a woman of sixty-seven who had spent forty years standing in front of music rooms full of children and had never once been in a hurry when something important was happening. She wore a dark blue dress and a silver brooch in the shape of a treble clef, and her white hair was pinned up in the neat coil she had worn since she was thirty. She climbed the side steps without assistance, crossed the stage to stand beside the chairman, folded her hands in front of her, and waited.
The other two judges followed her: a retired school principal with a careful, lined face, and a dance teacher from Des Moines who judged the pageant every year. They took their places a little behind Henrietta, the way people do when they know who among them carries the most weight in a room, and they stood quietly, watching, their faces grave.
The chairman turned to Henrietta. "Mrs. Loomis," he said, "you have judged this pageant for — how many years?"
"Eleven," she said. Her voice was clear and dry and precise, the voice of a woman who had spent a lifetime correcting pitch and would not tolerate a flat note in anything, least of all in the truth. "Eleven years, Mr. Chairman. And I have taught music in this county for forty. I know what a fair contest looks like. I have run a great many of them. And I know what a fixed one looks like, because I have seen two, and I have never forgotten either of them."
"And did you see what happened backstage tonight?"
Henrietta did not answer at once. She looked at Zara, and her face — stern, exact, the face that had terrified three generations of schoolchildren into practising their scales — softened by a degree that only someone watching closely would have noticed. Then she looked back at the chairman, and then out at the audience, and she spoke in the same clear, dry voice, as if she were giving testimony in a courtroom, which in a sense she was.
"I saw it through the gap in the curtain," she said. "I had stepped backstage to find the stage manager about the order of the speeches, and I saw Mrs. Fontaine standing behind this child at the vanity, and I saw her throw the contents of a jar across the child's face. It was liquid stage glitter, from the costume table. I saw the child's face in the mirror. I saw her gasp. And I saw her decide — in the space of a few seconds, with glitter dripping off her chin — not to cry, and not to run. I have seen courage in children before, but I do not believe I have ever seen it arrive quite so fast, or sit quite so still."
A murmur ran through the theatre at that — a low, shocked sound, quickly swallowed — and Henrietta waited for it to pass, the way she had waited out a thousand restless classrooms, before she went on.
"I did not intervene in that moment," she said, "and I want to be plain about why. The child was not in danger. The glitter was harmless — washable, made for the stage, nothing that could hurt her. And she had already made her decision. It was not my place to make it for her. What I could do, I did. I went to my bag, where I keep my own copies of the score sheets — because in forty years of judging, I have learned never to trust a single copy of anything — and I took the original signed sheets for the talent round, put them in an envelope, and in the corridor, before she went on, I gave them to Zara. I told her only that they were hers to do with as she chose. What she chose to do with them, you have all just seen."
She turned then, fully, toward Zara, and she held out one hand — not reaching for the envelope, but asking, with the open palm of a woman who knows how to wait for a child to be ready.
"May I see them, dear?" she said. "Just so that everyone here can hear it from me, as well as from you."