The deed was a photocopy, recorder's stamp and all: a Phase Two townhome
unit — Unit 4, founding resident — deeded out of the development's holding
company to Bethany Halloran. Marge's daughter. A young woman Luke had
seen perhaps four times in his life, at the clubhouse Christmas walk, holding
a cup of cider with the expression of someone being stored in a life rather
than living it. The deed had been recorded three weeks before the first of the
option contracts was signed.
"She was paid before the lots were even optioned," Luke said, quietly. "The
campaign wasn't persuasion. It was a delivery schedule. She wasn't trying to
change our minds, Erin. She was shipping us."
"That's the reading I'd take into a courtroom," Callahan said. "She took the
consideration first and manufactured the voluntariness after. The unit, the
minibar, the eleven cases — Marge Halloran has been spending the proceeds
of this thing in public for a year, in green glass and clubhouse walnut,
because she believed the paper only talked to her."
"Ferro said almost exactly that."
"Ferro is a good detective." She closed the folder with a finality that was
almost gentle. "Pryce, through counsel, has begun the distancing. Their
statement uses the phrase a rogue association president is not our company's
policy, which is law-firm for a man pushing a chair back from a table.
Everyone who ate with Marge for twenty years is preparing to be the one
who didn't know her. I mention it because you'll hear it suggested that this
63
makes the campaign hers alone. It does not. It makes it an enterprise with a
foreman. The enterprise is what interests the United States Attorney."
"What interests her more," Luke said, "is the part where my pool got me
arrested in my own yard by your alarm."
Callahan did not correct the grammar of that, which was her own kind of
honesty. "We'll come to the fork," she said. "It's why I brought the folder
myself. But not tonight. Tonight you should read the deed again and
remember that the woman who did this kept the paperwork in her own
clubhouse, in a drawer, in order. Men like Aldana employ men to burn paper.
Marge Halloran filed hers. There's a sermon in that somewhere, but I'll leave
it to Ferro."
Gerald Halloran came to the door on the Monday evening, holding nothing.
Luke saw him from the kitchen window first — a man in his late sixties
standing at the edge of the porch light in a cardigan buttoned wrong at the
bottom, doing the thing men of his generation had been raised to do outside a
closed door, which was to compose himself as if composure were a coat he
could still put on. Luke opened the door before the knock finished forming.
He had known, in the way a street knows things, that this visit existed
somewhere in the week. He had not known it would be like being visited by
the part of the story that had also been living inside the house with her.
"Five minutes," Gerald said. "I have no right to them. I'll take three if you'll
tell me when they're up."
"You can have coffee," Luke said. "It takes longer than five minutes and it's
better than standing."
They sat at the kitchen table where Ferro's box had been, where Callahan's
folder had been, and Luke understood that his table had become the street's
64
confessional and that Gerald, who had sold insurance for thirty years, knew
exactly what room he was in. He had the careful, ruined dignity of a man
who had read his own policy and discovered the exclusion.
"I did not know about the glass," Gerald said. "I want that on whatever
record you're keeping, and then I'll never say it again, because a man who
says it twice is asking to be believed more than he deserves. Twenty years
I've eaten dinner across from that woman. I knew she was hard. I knew the
street called her things at their own tables. I did not know she was — " He
stopped, and Luke watched him try the word in his mind the way a man tries
a step on ice he already knows is thin. "I did not know she was the kind of
hard that cuts locks. I'll leave it there. I can't make the other word fit my
wife, Mr. Donovan. I've tried all week, like a coat. It doesn't fit, and I know
what that says about the man trying it on."
"It says you ate dinner with her for twenty years," Luke said. "It doesn't say
anything worse."
"You are kinder than the arithmetic," Gerald said. "I've done the arithmetic.
That's why I'm here." He turned his cup a quarter turn, a quarter turn back —
an adjuster's hands, still making their small assessments. "The plant she
worked at — the cable plant, out by the interstate — it closed when she was
forty-four. She'd been there since she was nineteen. She ran the floor
scheduling, which means she ran four hundred people without the title for it,
and one Friday there was a cake and a certificate and a man from Ohio she'd
never met explaining the future. She came home and sat in that house for two
years, Mr. Donovan. I watched it like weather I couldn't change. Then the
association needed a secretary." His mouth moved, not quite a smile. "The
association was the only institution that ever told Marjorie Halloran she was