HOA President Dumped Broken Glass Into His Pool for a Week—Then the FBI Alarm Went Off While He Was Filming Her

Chapter 29

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

permitted in the room. That was at Wren's request as much as the protocol's:

she had asked, at breakfast, in the tone she used for split times and other

non-negotiables, whether this was something she could do without him

standing behind her chair, and he had said of course, and meant it, and then

sat in the corridor for forty minutes learning what the word meant.

He could hear the cadence through the door and none of the words. Her voice

went at its own pace — question, answer, question, answer — the rhythm of

a person swimming laps in a lane with nobody else in it. Once there was a

pause long enough that he stood up without deciding to, and sat down again.

Once, briefly, she laughed at something, one short note, and the sound went

through him like a hand on his shoulder: the interview was hers. She was not

77

describing the worst week of her summer the way a victim describes it. She

was describing it the way she would describe a race she intended to win —

the start, the turn, the wall. Ferro had asked her, Luke learned later, whether

she had been frightened, and she had considered the question with the

seriousness she gave to questions about her stroke mechanics, and answered

that she had been frightened afterward, on the deck, doing the arithmetic of

how close her feet had come. At the time, she said, she had mostly been

angry at the interruption to her training. The statement was forty minutes

long. It rested on the facts the way a swimmer rests on the water: completely,

and without visible effort.

Ferro came out first, with the recorder and a folder, and stood a moment in

the corridor the way men do when they are deciding how much of a room to

carry out of it with them.

"She swims like she talks, Mr. Donovan," he said. "Straight at the wall."

Wren came out behind him with her bag over her shoulder and her hair still

damp from the morning's session, and she looked at her father sitting in the

plastic chair with his hands folded and read the whole forty minutes off his

face in one glance.

"It went fine, Dad," she said. "You're doing the thing with your hands."

He unclasped them. "I'm not doing a thing."

"You are, but it's fine." She hoisted the bag higher. "Can we go? I have to be

back in the water at four, and Coach says if I'm late because of lawyers he'll

put it in the log."

The plea machinery began to move the following week, in the form it always

takes when a case has nowhere left to go: a letter. Marge's counsel wrote to

Osei on heavy paper and requested a meeting at Osei's earliest convenience

78

to discuss resolution, which Osei read aloud to Luke over the phone with the

dry appreciation of a woman translating a flag of surrender out of legal

French. There would be conditions attempted and mostly refused. There

would be a request for the endangerment count to be characterized

downward, which Osei rejected in the same tone she used for scheduling

conflicts. What there would not be, everyone now understood, was a trial —

because a trial had the Verde Alto paper in one exhibit box and the footage in

another, and between the two of them there was no version of Marjorie

Halloran that a jury could be asked to believe in. The only questions left

were arithmetic: how many counts, how much of it consecutive, and whether

the woman who had run Saltmarsh Landing for twenty years would say the

word guilty in a courtroom herself, or make the county spend the money to

hear twelve neighbors say it for her.

The association held its reckoning on a Wednesday night, in the clubhouse

where Marge Halloran had presided over two decades of annual meetings

like a mayor in a town she had founded. Luke did not go. He had decided

that the neighborhood's business was the neighborhood's, and that his

presence in the room would make it about the wrong thing; but half the street

seemed to pass his porch afterward in ones and twos, and by the end of the

week he had the shape of the evening assembled from a dozen accounts that

all agreed on the essentials and differed only in where people had been

sitting when they started to cry.

Howard Lindt presided. Lindt had been vice president for eleven years,

which in Marge's association meant he had spent eleven years as the

signature you got when Marge was on vacation, and he ran the meeting, by

every account, like a man cleaning a wound in public — not enjoying it, not

flinching from it, aware that the hurting was part of the point. Marge's chair

79

stood at the head table where it always stood. Somebody had removed her

nameplate earlier in the day and then, thinking better of it, or worse of it, put

it back, and it sat there through the whole meeting in front of the empty

chair, which several people told Luke was the worst thing in the room: worse

than the arrest video, which by then every person in Saltmarsh Landing had

seen a hundred times, worse than the documents, because the nameplate was

ordinary. It was the meeting going on with her name still typed on it.

News in the same category

HOA President Dumped Broken Glass Into His Pool for a Week—Then the FBI Alarm Went Off While He Was Filming Her

45 Part