HOA President Dumped Broken Glass Into His Pool for a Week—Then the FBI Alarm Went Off While He Was Filming Her

Chapter 31

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"You should know what your street did," Lindt said, "since you wouldn't

come watch it."

"I watched the street do it for twenty years," Luke said. "From the other

side."

82

Lindt accepted that with a wince that was not performed. He had signed

things, in eleven years of vice presidency, that he had not read the way a man

reads things he expects to answer for; the audit the association had just voted

for would open books with his signature in them too, and he had seconded

the motion, and he wanted that on some record somewhere, even if the

record was only this porch. "I keep thinking about Ethel," he said. "Not

afraid. Tired. I was both, if we're keeping books tonight, and I was the

second one longer."

"You're keeping better books now," Luke said, and Lindt laughed once,

without much in it, and drank his coffee, and did not stay long. Men of his

generation and formation did not linger over a confession. He had come to

deliver it, and he delivered it, and he went home across the street to a house

where, for the first time in twenty years, nobody was afraid of the mail.

Osei called that Friday with the state of the negotiations, which she

summarized the way she summarized everything, as a list of doors closing.

Marge's counsel had abandoned the request to characterize the endangerment

count downward. He had abandoned the request for a sentencing cap in

exchange for cooperation, there being nothing, on inspection, for his client to

cooperate about that the exhibits did not say better. What remained under

discussion was the number of counts to which she would plead and whether

two of them would run together or end to end, and Osei said the word

consecutive the way other people say the weather is turning. "He's a good

lawyer doing a bad job's last honest work," she said. "He's buying his client

the smallest true version of this. The version where she pleads to what the

footage shows, and not to what twenty years of minutes suggest."

"And if she won't say it?" Luke asked.

"Then we try it, and she loses in front of her neighbors instead of in front of a

83

judge." Osei turned a page he could hear. "She'll say it, Mr. Donovan. They

always reach the morning where saying it is the cheapest thing left. Hers is

coming."

The machine made one more move, near the end, and it was the kind of

move that told Luke everything about how it had run for twenty years: when

it could no longer work on the record, it worked around the edges of it.

The car came down his street twice in nine days, slowly, the way cars move

when the driver is reading house numbers — except that the driver was not

reading house numbers. The first pass, Luke saw from the kitchen and

thought little of it; Saltmarsh Landing had become briefly famous, and fame

brings traffic. The second pass he saw from the yard, and this time the

passenger-side window was down and a phone was up, held at the practiced

angle of a man photographing without aiming, and the car did not slow at

Marge Halloran's house at all. It slowed at his.

He called Callahan. Callahan, to her credit, did not tell him he was imagining

things, and by the weekend her countersurveillance people had the man

identified and his client named, and she delivered the findings on his porch

with an expression Luke had not seen on her before: embarrassment, on

behalf of the opposition. The photographer was a licensed private

investigator out of Columbia, and he was not working for Rafael Aldana. He

was not working for anyone in the federal case at all. He was retained by the

firm handling Marjorie Halloran's civil and insurance matters — the lawyers

building the countersuit, the one whose draft complaint described Luke

Donovan as a man who had engineered the alarm incident: lured a

neighborhood volunteer onto his property, staged an emergency,

manufactured a federal spectacle out of a community dispute. The

investigator had been photographing vehicles on the street, visitors, patterns

84

— the raw material of a theory in which Luke was the author of everything

and Marge was a woman who had wandered into his bookkeeping.

Luke listened to all of it without interrupting, and what he felt was not anger.

He had been investigated by experts. For two years his accounts had been

taken apart by forensic accountants who could find a dollar in a haystack of

dollars; his testimony had been tested by defense teams who did that work

the way surgeons do theirs. This — a man in a sedan with a phone, sniffing

for a countersuit on behalf of a woman photographed carrying glass to a

child's pool — this was amateur work, and it saddened him in a way the

experts never had. The machine had run a neighborhood for twenty years on

letterhead and momentum and other people's fatigue, and now, at the end,

this was what was left of it: not even competence. Just the reflex, twitching.

The reflex finished the state case. The photographs had been taken after the

court entered its no-contact order — an order that bound Marge Halloran

and, as her counsel had been reminded in writing, those acting on her behalf.

Osei added the photographs and the investigator's retainer to the file as its

newest exhibit, and Marge's criminal counsel, a man who had spent three

News in the same category

HOA President Dumped Broken Glass Into His Pool for a Week—Then the FBI Alarm Went Off While He Was Filming Her

45 Part