The association's new counsel read the Phase Two paper into the record in
extracts, in the flat voice of a man being paid not to have an opinion about it.
The options on the marsh parcels, contingent on approvals that had not been
sought. The minutes of meetings at which those approvals had been granted,
dated before the meetings occurred. The townhome plans, the density
waivers, the landscaping easements drawn through lots whose owners had
never been shown a map. And then, near the end of the reading, Unit 4: a
deed, recorded in the county in March, conveying the first and best of the
Pryce Landing townhomes to Bethany Halloran, consideration listed as
services rendered. Twenty years of quorum calls and bake-sale ledgers, and it
turned out the presidency had a price list, and the price list had her daughter's
name on it in the county's own hand.
Then the Pryce letter. Lindt read it himself. Pryce Landing Development
regretted to inform the association that, owing to circumstances which had
made the project a subject of legal and journalistic attention, it was
withdrawing from Phase Two in its entirety, effective immediately, and
would pursue no further development interest in Saltmarsh Landing. The
room, Luke was told, made a sound at that which was not a cheer and not a
groan but something in between that neither of those words covers — the
sound of a fever deciding, in a body that has been sick a long time, to break.
80
The votes went the way votes go when a community has already made up its
mind in its kitchens. The removal of Marjorie Halloran as president, ratified
by a count so lopsided the secretary read it twice out of disbelief. An
independent forensic audit of twenty years of association books, the auditor
to be chosen by lot from a list of firms none of the board had ever employed.
The reform slate, item by item: competitive bidding on every contract above
a threshold a first-year bookkeeper could not have driven a townhome
through; minutes published to every homeowner within ten days of any
meeting, forever, in full; term limits, two and out, for every office including
the one that no longer had anyone in it. It was not a second hearing. Nobody
performed outrage for the cameras, because there were no cameras. It was
slower and sadder than that — a body metabolizing a long sickness, grief
moving through the anger like weather through a house with the windows
open, and underneath it all the peculiar embarrassment of people who had
been governed, and known it, and said nothing, adding up the years.
Ethel Kaminski stood near the end. Ethel was eighty-one and had served on
the landscaping committee since the first phase was mud, and she did not use
the microphone, and the room quieted itself to hear her the way rooms do for
the one person present who has nothing left to protect.
"I would like the record to show that some of us were not afraid of Marjorie,"
she said. "We were just tired. There is a difference, and the difference is why
it worked."
She sat down. Nobody applauded. Several people, afterward, could not
explain why that had been the moment they cried.
Bethany Halloran was waiting on the clubhouse steps when the meeting let
out, or was found there — the accounts differed — with two reporters who
had been covering the arrest and smelled the second act. What she said was
81
captured cleanly enough that Luke heard it in her own voice on the late news,
standing in his kitchen with a dish towel in his hands: that she had never
asked for a townhome. That she had not known the deed existed until a
lawyer used the phrase in a sentence with her name in it. That Unit 4, when
the reporter described it to her — the marsh view, the deep porch, the best lot
in Phase Two — was the first she had heard of any of it, and that she kept
being asked to react to a gift the way you react to a gift, and she could not,
because nobody gives a daughter a house in secret unless the house is the
payment and the daughter is the address you send it to. She cried then, on
camera, with the particular helplessness of a person discovering the shape of
her own life in public. Luke turned the television off. He found that he
believed her, entirely, and that believing her did not make anything simpler.
The machine had used her name the way it had used the minutes and the
options and the marsh — as an instrument that did not need to know what it
was for. He was sorry for her in a way that had no use to either of them, and
he stood in his kitchen a while with the towel in his hands before he hung it
up and went to bed.
Howard Lindt came to the porch the morning after the meeting,
unannounced, with two paper cups of coffee and the air of a man who has
been awake since before the vote count. He had chaired the thing, he said,
and he had gone home and sat in his carport for an hour, and his wife had
finally come out and told him to either come inside or go and say the rest of
it to the person it belonged to. So here he was.