"You are safe now," Marcus said again, because he needed her to hear it more than once, and because he needed to hear himself say it. "No one is going to take you away from this room. There is a nurse outside the door, and Ava is with Mrs. Delgado down the hall, and I am right here."
Elena nodded, a small movement that cost her more than it should have. Her throat was still raw, and the nurse had left a cup of water with a straw on the table beside the bed. Marcus lifted it for her, and she took a careful sip, then another, before she spoke.
"It was someone I trusted," she said, her voice low and rough. "That is the hardest part to say. I did not fall into that room by accident, Marcus. I did not wander there. Someone put me there. Someone I let into our house, someone I let near Ava, someone who knew where the pool was and when you would be away."
Marcus felt his jaw tighten, but he kept his voice steady. He had spent fourteen months learning how to be steady in front of other people while his life fell apart inside, and now he used all of that practice for her. "Tell me as much as you can," he said. "And if you need to stop, we stop. There is no hurry tonight. The police are already here, and they will listen when you are ready."
"The woman in our house is not who you think she is," Elena said. "I know that sounds impossible. I know what she looks like, and I know what you have been told. But she is not Vanessa. Not the Vanessa I knew. The real Vanessa would never have done this."
Marcus stared at her. The name sat between them like something solid. Vanessa Cole had been in his house for months, had cooked in his kitchen, had read to Ava at bedtime, had worn a ring he had given her and talked about a wedding. He had believed he was rebuilding a life. Elena was telling him the foundation of that life had been a lie.
"How do you know?" he asked, quietly.
"Her voice," Elena said. "In the dark, when she came to the room, I learned her voice the way you learn a sound in a house at night. It was close to Vanessa's, but it was not Vanessa's. It was harder at the edges. And she was careful about her hands. She always kept her left hand turned away from me, or she wore a glove, or she kept it in her pocket. Once, when she was in a hurry, I saw it. There is a small scar on her left hand, here, from a kitchen burn. I remember Vanessa telling me once that her sister had burned her hand on a stove when they were girls. Vanessa did not have that scar."
She stopped to breathe, and Marcus waited. The monitor beside the bed beeped in its slow, even rhythm, and outside the window the late light was fading over the hospital car park.
"She found me after the boat," Elena said. "I remember the water, and then I remember the shore, and then I remember her face above me. I was too weak to move. I thought she was going to help me. She gave me water, and then she gave me something that made everything go dark again. When I woke up, I was in that room under the pool, and the door was shut, and I could hear the water above me sometimes, very faint, when someone swam."
Marcus closed his eyes for a second. He could picture it too clearly, and he did not want to picture it at all, but Elena needed him to stay with her in the telling, not turn away from it.
"She came back," Elena said. "Not every day. Sometimes two days would pass, sometimes three. She brought food in bags, and water in bottles, and sometimes medicine. She told me if I made a noise, no one would hear me, and if I tried to leave, I would die in the walls. She told me you believed I was dead, and Ava believed I was dead, and that it was better for everyone if I stayed quiet. She said she was taking care of Ava now, and that Ava was happy, and that I should be grateful she had not left me on the shore."
Elena squeezed his hand, weakly. "You did not know," she said. "She made sure you did not know. She wore my perfume. She slept in my old bedroom. She learned the way I left my books on the table. She was very good at being someone else, Marcus. That is why you have to be careful now. If you go home and accuse her with nothing but my word, she will cry, and she will say I am confused from being ill, and people will believe her because she has had months to become believable."