Detective Bennett nodded. "Cedar Falls is a three-hour drive. I have already called the police there, and they have confirmed there is a Vanessa Cole working at the school library, and that she has lived there quietly for years. I would like you to come with me to meet her, Mr. Hayes, because she may be frightened when the police arrive, and a familiar face, even a face she does not know well, may help her understand we are not there to accuse her. But I need you to promise me something first."
"Anything," Marcus said.
"Promise me you will listen before you judge," Detective Bennett said. "If she is the real Vanessa, she is also a victim in this. Her name was used. Her face was used. She may have lost jobs, or friends, or a sense of safety, because of what her sister did in her name. She may be angry, or she may be ashamed, even though she did nothing wrong. Let her tell her story first."
"I promise," Marcus said. "I will listen."
They left early the next morning, before Ava woke, and drove north to Cedar Falls. The town was small, with a main street, a school, a library, a bakery, and houses with gardens that looked tended and loved. The school library was at the back of the school, a warm room with low shelves, and posters on the walls, and a desk near the window where a woman was stamping books and talking softly to a boy who was choosing a story about space.
Marcus knew at once, and at the same time did not know, who she was. She had the same face as the woman in his house, the same hair, the same shape, but everything else was different. She moved differently, softer, less certain, and when she looked up and saw two strangers at the door, she bit her lower lip, a small, nervous habit, and her right hand moved, almost without thinking, to the thin gold ring on her right hand, turning it round and round.
"Vanessa Cole?" Detective Bennett said, gently.
"Yes," the woman said, and her voice was like the voice in Marcus's house, and not like it, softer at the edges, with a warmth that the other voice had never had. "Can I help you? Is something wrong at the school?"
"Nothing is wrong at the school," Detective Bennett said. "We have come from another town, because we need your help with something very serious, and because we believe you may be in danger of being blamed for something you did not do. My name is Detective Laura Bennett, and this is Marcus Hayes. May we talk somewhere private?"
Vanessa's face went pale, and she bit her lip again, harder this time, and looked at the boy, who was watching them with wide eyes. "Of course," she said. "There is a small office behind the desk. Mrs. Thompson, could you watch the library for ten minutes?"
In the office, with the door closed, Detective Bennett explained, slowly and carefully, what had happened. She told Vanessa about Elena, about the room under the pool, about the fourteen months, about the woman living in Marcus's house who looked like her, and who had used her name. She did not rush. She let each fact settle before she gave the next one.
Vanessa listened without interrupting, her hand turning the gold ring, her teeth catching her lower lip again and again. When Detective Bennett finished, Vanessa was silent for a long moment, and then she said, very quietly, "My sister. Veronica. She has always wanted what other people had. When we were girls, she would take my clothes and wear them, and tell people she was me, to get out of trouble. I thought she had stopped. I thought she had grown out of it. I did not know she had taken my whole name and built a life with it."
"Did you know she was living with Mr. Hayes?" Detective Bennett asked.
"No," Vanessa said. "I have not seen Veronica in three years. We argued, about money, about her borrowing and not paying back, and I told her I needed space. She sent me a birthday card last year, from an address I did not recognise, and I did not reply. I thought she was living somewhere else, working somewhere else. I never imagined this. I never imagined she could do this to another woman, to a child."
Marcus watched her as she spoke, and he saw what Elena had described. Her left hand was smooth, with no scar. Her right hand wore the thin gold ring, a ring the woman in his house had never worn. She bit her lip when she was nervous, a habit the woman in his house did not have. She did not wear Elena's perfume. She did not speak like someone who had practised being someone else. She spoke like someone who was shocked to learn she had been impersonated, and who was trying to understand how it had happened.