MY SIX-YEAR-OLD DAUGHTER INTERRUPTED MY PROPOSAL, SCREAMING THAT HER MOTHER WAS TRAPPED UNDER THE POOL—THEN I FOUND A LOCKED METAL HATCH BENEATH THE WATER

Chapter 24

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

He played the clips, one after another. The footage was grainy, in black and white, but clear enough. A woman, carrying a bag in each hand, walking from the back door of the mansion to the pool house, late at night, sometimes at one in the morning, sometimes at two. She wore a dark coat, and a scarf, and she looked over her shoulder before she opened the pool house door. She stayed inside for ten or fifteen minutes, and then she came out with empty bags, and walked back to the house, and the light went out.

The dates on the footage matched Elena's notebook. The nights Elena had written down a visit were the nights Mr. Alvarez's camera had recorded a visit. The nights Elena had written down no visit were nights when the camera showed nothing, only the empty path and the dogs sleeping by the gate.

"Did you ever see her face?" Detective Bennett asked.

"Not clearly," Mr. Alvarez said. "The camera is not that good at night. But I saw her hands once, when she dropped a bag and bent to pick it up. She had a small scar on her left hand. I remember it because my sister has a burn scar like that, from a kitchen accident, and I thought, that poor woman, she must have hurt herself cooking."

Marcus felt his breath catch. The scar again. The same small detail Elena had described, seen by a neighbour who had no reason to invent it, on a night when Elena said Veronica had come to the room.

"Mr. Alvarez, this is very important," Detective Bennett said. "Would you be willing to give a formal statement, and to let us keep a copy of this footage?"

"Yes," Mr. Alvarez said. "Of course. I wish I had said something sooner. I told my wife, and she said not to interfere in other people's business, and I listened to her, and now I wish I had not. If I had called the police that first night, maybe your wife would have been found sooner."

"You did what you thought was right at the time," Marcus said, and he meant it. "And you are helping now. That matters."

They left Mr. Alvarez's house with a copy of the footage on a drive, and with the pharmacy records in a folder, and with Elena's notebook in an evidence bag. Detective Bennett put them all in the car, carefully, as if they were fragile, which in a way they were. They were the proof that Elena's story was not a dream, or a confusion, or a mistake. They were dates, and times, and faces, and hands, all pointing the same way.

Back at the station, a technician had opened the phone found in the pool house. It was not Veronica's everyday phone. That phone was in her bag, with her normal contacts and her normal photos. This phone was older, and it had only a few contacts, and its messages were short and careful. They were in Veronica's name, sent to a number that belonged to a cheap pay-as-you-go SIM, and they talked about supplies, and about times, and about keeping Elena quiet, and about what to do if Marcus came home early.

One message, sent on a night Elena's notebook listed as a visit, read, in plain words, that the supplies were low and more water was needed. Another, sent a week later, said the medicine was bought and the visit would be late. Another, sent the month before Elena was found, said that Marcus was talking about a wedding date, and that everything had to be quiet until then, because a wedding would make the house and the money secure.

Marcus read the summaries Detective Bennett gave him, not the full messages, because she said the full messages would be presented formally later, and because she did not want him to have to carry every word. But even the summaries were enough. The phone had been used for one purpose, and one purpose only: to manage the secret, and to keep Elena hidden while Veronica built a life on top of her silence.

"The phone, the camera, the pharmacy, the notebook, and your wife's identification," Detective Bennett said, as they sat in her small office with the door closed. "Each one alone could be argued with. Together, they are very strong. But there is still one piece missing, Mr. Hayes, and it is the piece your wife asked for. We need to find the real Vanessa Cole, and we need to hear from her, in her own words, where she has been, and what she has been doing, while her sister was living in your house."

"She lives in Cedar Falls," Marcus said. "That is what Elena told me. She works as a school librarian. She had no idea."

News in the same category

MY SIX-YEAR-OLD DAUGHTER INTERRUPTED MY PROPOSAL, SCREAMING THAT HER MOTHER WAS TRAPPED UNDER THE POOL—THEN I FOUND A LOCKED METAL HATCH BENEATH THE WATER

45 Part