A ribbon. A small white ribbon, frayed at the ends, the kind a woman might tie around her wrist for luck, or for comfort, or simply because she liked the way it looked against her skin.
Marcus knew that ribbon. He had seen Elena tie it around her wrist on the morning she disappeared, standing in their bedroom in front of the mirror, laughing at herself for being superstitious, saying it was silly but she was going to wear it anyway, because the sea could be unpredictable and a little luck never hurt anyone. He had watched her knot it, and he had kissed her wrist, and he had told her she looked beautiful, and he had watched her walk out of the house and down to the boat, the white ribbon bright against her skin in the morning sun.
His hand closed around the ribbon in the water, and he held it, and he looked down through the narrow gap in the hatch, into the darkness below.
At first there was only darkness. A deep, close darkness, the darkness of a sealed room, of a place with no windows and no light. And then, as his eyes adjusted, he saw movement. A pale shape, moving slowly in the dark, reaching up toward the gap, toward the light, toward him.
A hand.
A human hand, pale and thin, its fingers spread, reaching up through the cold water, trembling, searching.
And then, from below, through the water, through the metal, through the narrow gap in the hatch, Marcus heard three soft, metallic knocks. Knock. Knock. Knock. Slow. Deliberate. As if someone below were tapping on the underside of the hatch with a knuckle, or a ring, or a small, hard object, trying to say, I am here, I am here, I am still here.
Marcus let go of the handle. He pushed himself up, kicking hard for the surface, his lungs burning, his heart hammering, the white ribbon clutched tight in his fist. He broke the surface with a gasp, water streaming from his hair and his face, and he sucked in air, and he looked toward the edge of the pool.
Vanessa was standing at the pool edge, her champagne dress darkened at the hem where water had splashed onto it, her hands pressed to her mouth, her eyes wide. "Get out!" she shouted. "Marcus, get out of the pool! Get out right now!"
He swam to the edge and held onto the tiles, breathing hard, water dripping from his chin. "What is under the pool, Vanessa?" he asked. "Tell me. What is under there?"
"Nothing!" she said, too quickly, too loudly. "There is nothing under there! It is just an old hatch, an old maintenance hatch, it has been there for years, it means nothing, Marcus, please, get out, you are frightening Ava, you are frightening everyone —"
And then she stopped. Her mouth stayed open for a second too long. Her eyes widened further. And Marcus saw, in that moment, the exact second when she realised what she had just said.
"You should not have opened it," she whispered.
The words were quiet, but in the sudden silence on the terrace they sounded very loud. The guests went still. Thomas Reed stopped speaking into his phone. Ava, who had been standing with the woman in the green dress, pulled away and ran to the edge of the pool.
"Mummy knocked three times," Ava said, her voice clear and certain, as if she were stating a fact she had known all along. "I heard her. She knocked three times, Daddy. Like she does on my bedroom door. Knock, knock, knock."
Vanessa turned then, sharply, away from Marcus and away from Ava, and she rushed toward the stone wall at the far end of the terrace, toward the small grey panel set into the stone, the pool control panel, with its rows of buttons and its blinking lights. Her heels clicked fast on the marble. Her dress flew out behind her. Her hand reached for the panel, fingers outstretched, reaching for a button.
Marcus was out of the pool before he knew he had moved. He was soaking wet, his shirt clinging to his chest, water pooling around his bare feet on the marble, and he crossed the terrace in three long strides and caught Vanessa's wrist in his hand, just before her fingers could touch the panel.
"Do not touch it," he said.
His voice was low and steady, but his hand was firm around her wrist, and he did not let go. Vanessa tried to pull away, and he held on, not hard enough to hurt her, but hard enough to stop her.