Under the bed, in a small cloth bag, was a key on a ribbon. The ribbon was faded blue, and the key was old, with a shape Marcus did not recognise. Elena had told Detective Bennett about it in a short conversation that morning, before Marcus arrived: she had found the key in the room when she first woke there, tucked into a crack in the wall, and she had kept it on the ribbon around her wrist, because it made her feel less alone to hold something that belonged to the house, something that had been there before any of them.
"What does it open?" Marcus asked.
"We do not know yet," Detective Bennett said. "It may open a cupboard in the pool house, or a box, or an old door. We will try it, carefully, and we will log where it fits and where it does not. A key that belongs to this house, kept by your wife in that room, is another piece. It may not be the most important piece, but it is hers, and it shows she was thinking clearly, even in there."
They moved to the pool house next. It was a small building at the edge of the pool, with a changing room, a shower, a cupboard for towels and cleaning supplies, and a bench where Marcus sometimes sat in the summer. It smelled of chlorine and damp wood. On the bench, under a folded towel, Detective Bennett found a phone. It was an older phone, with a cracked screen, and it was turned off. When the second officer turned it on with gloves, the lock screen showed a photo of the pool at sunset, and the messages app, once they opened it with a warrant and a technician's help later that day, would show messages in Veronica's name, sent to a number no one in the house recognised, talking about supplies, and times, and keeping Elena quiet.
Marcus did not read the messages that morning. Detective Bennett told him, in general terms, what they contained, and that was enough. He stood in the pool house and looked at the bench, and at the cupboard, and at the small window that looked out over the water, and he tried to understand how a person could come here at night, carrying bags, and go back to the house, and make breakfast in the morning, and smile at a six-year-old child, as if none of it had happened.
In the main house, in the bedroom that had once been Elena's and that Veronica now used, Detective Bennett opened the wardrobe with Marcus's permission and looked, without touching more than she needed to, at what was there. Elena's perfume was on the dressing table, the bottle almost empty. Elena's books were still on the shelf, in the same order Elena had left them. A ring box was on the bedside table, open, empty, the ring itself on Veronica's hand when she left that morning, Marcus supposed, or in her bag. He picked up the box and closed it, and put it in his pocket, because he did not want to look at it any longer.
"She wore your wife's perfume," Detective Bennett said, quietly. "She slept in your wife's bedroom. Those are not crimes by themselves, Mr. Hayes, but they tell us about intent. They tell us she was not simply helping a friend. She was stepping into a life. She was practising being Elena's replacement, in the small ways first, and then in the larger ways."
"We will end that today," he said, finally. "The proposal is off. I will not marry her. I will return the ring box, and I will tell her, with the police present, that it is over. I do not want a scene. I want it to be clear, and lawful, and final."
"That is the right way," Detective Bennett said. "We will do it at the station, with a witness, and we will put it in writing. No shouting, no threats, no drama that she can use later to say she was treated unfairly. Just the facts, and the end of the engagement, and the request that she leave the house and not contact Ava or Elena."
They left the house and drove back to the hospital. Ava was still with Elena, drawing pictures on a pad the nurse had given her, pictures of a house with a pool and a sun and three stick figures holding hands. Elena was awake, and stronger, and she asked Marcus to sit with her for a few minutes before Detective Bennett spoke to her again.
"I remembered something else," Elena said. "About the scar. Veronica has a small scar on her left hand, from a kitchen burn. I saw it once when she reached for a bottle and her sleeve fell back. The real Vanessa does not have that scar. If you meet the real Vanessa, look at her left hand. It will be smooth. That is how you will know."