MY SIX-YEAR-OLD DAUGHTER INTERRUPTED MY PROPOSAL, SCREAMING THAT HER MOTHER WAS TRAPPED UNDER THE POOL—THEN I FOUND A LOCKED METAL HATCH BENEATH THE WATER

Chapter 23

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Marcus wrote it down in his own notebook, in his own hand, so he would not forget. A scar on the left hand. A gold ring on the right hand. A habit of biting the lower lip when nervous. Small details, but in a case about two women who looked the same, small details were the difference between truth and confusion.

Detective Bennett came in then, and spoke to Elena gently, for ten minutes, no more. Elena told her about the notebook, about the key, about the scar, about the voice in the dark. She did not cry. She spoke like someone who had waited a long time to be believed, and who was finally being believed, and who wanted to make every word count.

When Detective Bennett left, Elena took Marcus's hand again. "Find the real Vanessa," she said. "If she is alive, and if she does not know what her sister did, she deserves to know. And I deserve to meet her, not as an enemy, but as someone who was also used. Her name was used. Her face was used. That is a kind of harm too."

"I will find her," Marcus said. "Detective Bennett is already looking. And I will not let anyone blame her for what her sister did."

That afternoon, while Elena rested and Ava stayed with Mrs. Delgado in the hospital family room, Detective Bennett took Marcus to the pharmacy on the main street near their house. It was a small, bright shop with a bell over the door, and the pharmacist, a woman in her fifties named Mrs. Patel, recognised Marcus at once and asked after Elena, as if she had heard the news and did not quite know what to say about it.

"We need to check some purchase records," Detective Bennett said, showing her warrant and explaining, in simple terms, that they were looking for a pattern of medicine bought over the past fourteen months. "We are not accusing your shop of anything. We are looking for who bought what, and when."

Mrs. Patel nodded and went to the back room, and came back with a printout and a ledger. She was careful, and precise, and she did not gossip. She pointed to dates, one after another, where a woman matching Veronica's description had bought the same mild pain relief, the same stomach medicine, the same vitamins, and the same skin cream Elena's notebook listed. The amounts were small, never enough to draw attention, always paid in cash, always on a day when Elena's notebook said a visit had happened, or the day before.

"She came in the late afternoon, usually," Mrs. Patel said. "She was polite. She never asked for anything unusual. She said the medicine was for herself, for headaches, for a bad stomach. I did not think twice about it. Why would I? Lots of people buy those things."

"Did she ever come with anyone else?" Detective Bennett asked.

"No," Mrs. Patel said. "Always alone. And she always paid cash, which I remember because most people use a card now. She would count the notes out very carefully, as if she did not want to leave a trace. I thought she was just old-fashioned."

Marcus looked at the dates and felt a cold steadiness settle over him. The notebook and the pharmacy records matched, not once or twice, but again and again, across months. Elena had written down a visit on a Tuesday, and Mrs. Patel had sold medicine on a Monday. Elena had written down medicine on a Friday, and Mrs. Patel had sold it on a Thursday. It was a routine, as Detective Bennett had said, and routines left traces.

"Thank you," Detective Bennett said to Mrs. Patel. "You have been very helpful. We may need you to confirm this later, in a formal statement, but for now, this is enough."

From the pharmacy, they drove to the house next door to the mansion, where a neighbour named Mr. Alvarez lived with his wife and two dogs. He was a retired teacher, and he had a doorbell camera that looked out over his front path and, at an angle, over the side of Marcus's house and the path to the pool house. He had already spoken to the police the day Elena was found, and he had saved the footage, because he had thought, even then, that something about the night visits did not look right.

"I did not want to be nosy," Mr. Alvarez said, as he led them into his living room and opened the footage on his laptop. "But I walk the dogs late, and I kept seeing a light in the pool house after midnight, and a figure going back and forth with bags. At first I thought it was you, Mr. Hayes, checking the pool. Then I realised the figure was smaller, and it moved differently, and it always came from the main house, not from the street."

News in the same category

MY SIX-YEAR-OLD DAUGHTER INTERRUPTED MY PROPOSAL, SCREAMING THAT HER MOTHER WAS TRAPPED UNDER THE POOL—THEN I FOUND A LOCKED METAL HATCH BENEATH THE WATER

45 Part