Mrs. Alvarez told Elena about it afterward, at the school gate, with tears in her eyes, and Elena thanked her, and walked home with Ava, holding her hand, and Ava skipped a little, and Elena skipped a little too, just for a moment, because she could, because her legs were stronger now, and because her daughter was proud of her, and because that was a thing worth skipping for. At home, Ava taped a new picture to the fridge, next to the first one. This one showed five people, and a rabbit, and a swing, and a sun with a smiling face, and Ava had written, in wobbly letters underneath, “My family.” Elena looked at it for a long time, and then she kissed the top of Ava's head, and Ava laughed, and the house felt, for a moment, almost too full of light to hold.
Grace, too, was settling, in her own slow, three-year-old way. The visits grew a little longer, a little more frequent, always guided by Dr. Brooks, always with Sarah and Daniel close by, always with Grace able to say, in her own way, when she had had enough. She learned where the crayons were kept, in a tin on the low shelf, and she learned that Ava liked to share them, but that the yellow crayon was Ava's favourite, and that Grace could use it if she asked nicely, which she did, very nicely, every time. She learned that the soft rabbit, the one with the flopped ear, had a name, which was Rabbit, and that Ava's rabbit had a name too, which was Snow, and that the two rabbits were best friends, just like Ava and Grace were becoming best friends, and sisters, both at once, in the way that only small children can hold two truths so easily.
They shared a swing, too, in the garden, taking turns, Ava pushing Grace gently, counting to three, and then Grace pushing Ava, with Sarah's help, because Grace's arms were still small, and Ava laughing and saying, “Higher, Grace, higher,” and Grace laughing too, and pushing with all her might, and the swing going up, just a little, and then coming down again, and both girls shrieking with delight. They shared strawberries, and stories, and a blanket on the grass, where they lay on their tummies and looked at picture books together, Grace pointing at the pictures, Ava reading the words she knew, and making up the words she did not know, which Grace accepted without question, because Ava was her big sister, and big sisters knew things.
It happened slowly, and then, one bright morning in early autumn, Grace came to stay, with her small suitcase and her rabbit and her yellow dress, and Sarah and Daniel helped her unpack, and Ava helped her put her crayons in the tin on the low shelf, and Elena helped her make her bed, with the soft blue blanket, and Marcus hung her picture — the four people, holding hands — on the wall beside her bed, next to Ava's picture of five people and a rabbit and a swing and a smiling sun. Grace looked around her new room, and then she looked at Ava, and then she looked at Elena, and she said, “I live here now?” and Elena knelt down, so that they were eye to eye, and said, “Yes, love. You live here now. And Sarah and Daniel live in Brookfield, and they will visit, and you will visit them, and we will all be together, a lot.” Grace thought about this, and then she nodded, and then she climbed onto her bed, and patted the space beside her, and said, “Rabbit lives here too,” and Ava said, “And Snow lives here too,” and the two rabbits were placed side by side on the pillow, and Grace lay down between them, just to try the bed, and fell asleep within minutes, in the middle of the morning, with the sun coming through the yellow curtains, and Elena sat beside her, watching her breathe, and felt her heart fill up so completely that she thought it might spill over.
Months passed. The leaves turned and fell, the apples were picked, and Elena and Ava and Grace made pie, with Marcus eating most of the filling before it went into the dish. Sarah and Daniel came for pie, and Thomas Reed, and they sat on the new terrace, where the pool had once been, and ate pie with cream, and watched the girls play. The house, which had once held so much fear, now held pie, and laughter, and small feet on the stairs, and bread baking, and Elena walking in the garden in the morning light, her hair longer now, tied back with a ribbon.