that Ava's pictures were healthy, that they were her way of keeping her mother close, that he should let her draw as much as she needed to, and he had tried to follow that advice. He had praised the pictures. He had pinned some of them to the fridge. He had asked her, gently, to tell him about them, and she had told him, in her clear, serious voice, that Mummy was in the sky, that Mummy could see her, that Mummy liked the yellow sun best.
None of those pictures had ever shown a door under a pool. None of her stories had ever mentioned knocking, or glass, or a hand beating against anything. She had never woken in the night with a story like this. She had never run across a terrace in front of twenty people with terror in her face and a certainty in her voice that made the adults around her go quiet.
Thomas Reed was watching Ava now, Marcus noticed, with the steady, watchful look of a man who had known this family for years, who had been there on the day Marcus and Elena had moved into the house, who had helped carry boxes, who had stood on this same terrace with a beer in his hand and told Marcus that the infinity pool was the most ridiculous, beautiful thing he had ever seen. Thomas had watched Ava grow up. He had watched her take her first steps on the lawn below. He had given her a small wooden boat for her fifth birthday, a boat Elena had helped her float in the shallow end of the pool. Thomas knew Ava. He knew when she was playing, and when she was frightened, and when she was telling the truth as she understood it, and the look on his face now told Marcus that Thomas believed her fear, even if he did not yet understand what had caused it.
The guests were watching too, and Marcus could feel their uncertainty turning into something else, something heavier. A woman near the cake table whispered to her husband, her hand over her mouth. An older man, a business acquaintance Marcus barely knew, shifted his weight from one foot to the other and looked toward the house, as if he were wondering whether he should leave. A young couple near the stone wall held each other's hands. Nobody laughed. Nobody treated it as a joke. Whatever Ava had said, whatever she had seen, it had landed in the middle of a celebration and changed the shape of the evening entirely, and everyone on the terrace could feel it.
Marcus thought about the last fourteen months, about how carefully he had rebuilt a life that could hold both his grief and his daughter's childhood at the same time, and he thought about how fragile that rebuilding had been, how much of it had depended on not asking certain questions, on accepting that some things would never be explained. He thought about the investigators he had paid, good men with tired eyes, who had gone over the boat inch by inch and found no sign of a struggle, no sign of a fall, no sign of anything except an empty boat drifting on a calm sea. He thought about the divers, who had gone down in the cold water day after day, searching the seabed, searching the rocks, searching the places where the current might have carried a body, and who had come up each time shaking their heads. He thought about the coastline he had walked himself, mile after mile, in boots that had filled with sand, calling Elena's name, looking for a shoe, a bag, a ribbon, anything at all, and finding nothing. He thought about the night he had finally accepted that he might never know what had happened to his wife, and how he had sat in his car in the dark and wept, quietly, so that Ava would not hear him from the house.
He had learned to live with not knowing. He had learned to tell Ava that her mother loved her, and that her mother was at peace, and that they would always remember her. He had learned to keep Elena's voicemails, to keep her photographs, to keep the small white ribbon she had worn that morning in a drawer, because he had found a second ribbon like it in her jewellery box, and he had kept it as if keeping it might keep some small part of her close. He had not expected, on a warm evening fourteen months later, with a ring in his pocket and a new life waiting in front of him, to be told by his six-year-old daughter that his wife was not gone at all, but was under his own pool, behind a door, knocking to get out.