himself it was practical, that it was the largest room, that it made sense, but he had noticed the way she had rearranged the dressing table, the way she had moved Elena's photographs into a drawer, the way she had slept in that bed as if it had always been hers. He had said nothing about that either. He had not wanted to seem ungrateful, or difficult, or stuck in the past, when she was being so kind to Ava, so patient, so willing to build a life in a house that still held another woman's memory in every room.
He remembered smaller things, too, things he had dismissed at the time because they had seemed too strange to mean anything. The way Vanessa had known, on her first week in the house, exactly where the spare towels were kept in the linen cupboard, without Marcus showing her. The way she had known which light switch controlled the terrace lights, and which one controlled the pool lights, without asking. The way she had once, in the kitchen, reached for a particular mug, Elena's favourite mug, the blue one with the chipped handle, without hesitating, as if her hand had known where to go. He had laughed it off at the time. He had told himself she was observant, that she paid attention, that she was simply good at learning a new house quickly. Now, standing on the terrace with her hand trembling and her eyes flicking toward the pool, he wondered if he had been too willing to explain things away, too eager to believe in a simple, kind story because the true story, the story of losing Elena, had been so hard and so unresolved.
Behind him, the guests were murmuring again, their voices low and uncertain. A woman in a silver dress touched her husband's arm and whispered something Marcus could not hear. A man near the bar put down his champagne glass and folded his arms, watching Marcus with a frown. Thomas Reed had moved closer to Ava, standing just behind her, his hand resting lightly on her shoulder, ready to steady her if she needed it. Ava was still looking at her father, her eyes wide, her hands clasped together in front of her chest, her pink shoes planted firmly on the marble as if she were afraid that if she moved, the moment might break and her father might stop listening.
Vanessa's breathing was fast and shallow. Marcus could see the rise and fall of her chest under the champagne dress, and he could see the way her hands kept moving, touching her throat, smoothing her dress, reaching out and then pulling back, as if she did not know what to do with them. Her makeup was perfect, her hair was perfect, her dress was perfect, but her face was not. Her face was the face of a woman who had just seen something she had hoped never to see, a woman who had been holding a secret so tightly for so long that it was now slipping through her fingers in front of twenty people.
"Marcus," she said again, and her voice was softer now, almost pleading. "Please. Think about what you are doing. Think about Ava. She is frightened. She needs her father. She needs you to be calm. She needs you to take her inside and tell her it is all right, that her mummy is safe, that there is nothing to be afraid of. That is what a good father would do. That is what you have always done."
The words stung, because they were partly true. Marcus had always tried to be calm for Ava. He had always tried to be the steady one, the one who held her when she cried, the one who told her it was all right, even when he was not sure it was. But tonight, for the first time in fourteen months, he was not sure that calm was the right thing. Tonight, his daughter had run across a terrace and told him, with terror and certainty in her voice, that her mother was under the pool, and his girlfriend had grabbed his wrist and told him he had no idea what was down there, and the pool was waiting, dark and still, at the deep end, under the pale blue light, and Marcus knew that if he walked away now, if he took Ava inside and told her she was imagining it, he would never be able to forget the look on Vanessa's face, or the trembling of her hand, or the way she had glanced toward the water.
"You have no idea what is down there," he repeated, quietly, so that only she could hear him. "That is what you said."
"I misspoke," Vanessa said. "I was frightened. Ava frightened me. She frightened all of us. Marcus, please, come inside. Let me take Ava inside. Let us talk about this in the morning, when she is calm, when we are all calm."