Salesman Ordered an Older Customer Out—Then Learned Who Owned the Showroom

Chapter 25

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"I was afraid not to," she said. "A list is a promise, if you write a man's name on it and take his deposit. If you let the list lie, the promise lies with it."

Lena went after her, and she was nervous in the way young people are when they are telling the truth in a room full of older people who hold power. She described noticing the pattern, the same trucks appearing for sale online within days of delivery, at prices far above what the store had charged, and she described copying the delivery records on her own time, on the office copier after hours, because she had not known who else to show them to. She said she had not set out to be a whistleblower. She had set out to understand why a customer she had waited on had been told his truck was months away, and then had seen that same truck, by its color and its options and then by its number, listed for sale by a broker two states away. The board chair asked her whether she had been threatened. Lena said no, not in words. She said the store had simply grown quiet around her, which was its own kind of answer.

Frank testified after lunch. He did not tell the whole story of his life. He told the part that mattered to the board: that he had come to the store to buy a truck for his granddaughter's farm, that he had put his name on the list and left a deposit, that he had been told to look at the used lot, that he had been told the truck was months away, and that he had watched a truck he had been waiting for leave the store and reappear for sale at a price he could not have paid and should not have had to pay. He spoke about the money plainly, as he always did. A lifetime of savings, he said, and the sale of a small rental house his wife had kept up for years, the house where they had once planned to live when the plant closed. He did not dress it up. He said he had not come to the store to make a point. He had come to buy a truck, and he had expected the list to mean what it said.

The counsel asked him about the offer Callahan had made him, the quiet fix, the immediate truck at a markup. Frank said yes, it had been offered, in the manager's office, with the door closed. He said he had refused it, because it would have meant jumping the same line he had been standing in, and because it would have meant paying extra for the privilege of being treated fairly. He said he had not recorded the conversation. He had simply remembered it, the way he remembered the terms of every deal he had ever made, because a man who forgets the terms has already lost the deal.

Hank testified briefly and well. He said he was a contractor, that he had waited eight months for a truck he needed for his crew, that he had been told the allocation was delayed, and that he had later learned his truck had been sold to the broker and resold before he had even been called. He said he did not begrudge a dealer a profit. He begrudged being lied to about a list. The board chair nodded, and Hank sat down, and the room took a breath.

Callahan's lawyer then made his defense, and it was thinner in the hearing room than it had sounded, Frank suspected, in the office where it had been prepared. The lawyer argued that the store had the right to allocate vehicles as it saw fit, that the waitlist was a courtesy and not a contract, that the broker purchases were legitimate wholesale transactions, and that the fees in question were consulting payments for market services, not bribes. He argued that the computer list was the official list, and that Mabel's notebook was a personal record with no standing. He argued that no customer had been promised a specific truck on a specific date.

The board's counsel answered him with documents, one at a time, and the defense grew quieter with each one. The deposit receipts, which did promise a place in line. The factory allocation letters, which did say the trucks were for local retail customers. The title records, which showed the pattern too clearly to be coincidence: twenty-three trucks, fourteen months, the same broker, the same quick retitling, the same markup. The payment records, which Nakamura's audit had traced, showing facilitation fees of three thousand to five thousand dollars per truck, split between Callahan and Ashby, with Ashby's share the smaller of the two. The lawyer tried to call the fees something else, but the board chair cut him off, politely and firmly, and asked him whether the store had disclosed the fees to any customer on the waitlist. The lawyer paused. He said he would have to check. The chair said the board had already checked, and the answer was no.

News in the same category

Salesman Ordered an Older Customer Out—Then Learned Who Owned the Showroom

30 Part