Salesman Ordered an Older Customer Out—Then Learned Who Owned the Showroom

Chapter 26

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

When Colin was called, the room changed in a way Frank could feel. Colin stood, took the oath, and sat down, and for a moment he did not speak. His lawyer touched his arm, and Colin shook his head slightly, as if to say he would do this himself. He looked at the board, and then he looked at Frank, and he stayed looking at Frank while he spoke, which took more courage than Frank had expected from him.

He admitted it. He said he had taken the fees, smaller than Callahan's, three thousand on some trucks, less on others, and that he had told himself it was a bonus, a market adjustment, the way the business worked. He said he had known the waitlist was real, because he had seen Mabel's notebook, and he had known Frank's name was on it, and he had still steered Frank to the used lot and sold the allocation that should have gone to Frank's family to the broker. He said he had done it because he was chasing a quarterly bonus and because Callahan had told him everyone did it, and because it was easier to believe that than to look at the man in front of him and see a customer who had saved his whole life for a truck.

Then he turned fully toward Frank, and his voice, which had been steady, went rough at the edges.

"Mr. Marlowe," he said, "I am sorry. I judged you by your clothes and by what I thought you could afford, and I was wrong about both. You were the customer. I was supposed to take care of you, and I sold your place in line instead. I can't undo that. I can only say it here, where it counts, and try to do better from now on."

Frank did not answer right away. He looked at Colin, at the young man's hands, which were shaking slightly on the table, and at his face, which was not performing remorse but wearing it, plainly and uncomfortably. Frank thought about all the young men he had trained at the plant, the ones who had made mistakes and the ones who had learned from them, and about the difference between a man who apologizes to get out of trouble and a man who apologizes because he has finally seen what he did. He nodded, once, slowly.

"I hear you," Frank said. "That's a start."

The board chair thanked Colin, and Colin sat down, and the hearing moved on to its closing arguments, but Frank kept thinking about that nod, and about what a start was worth. It was not the truck. It was not the money. It was a door, left open, where before there had only been a wall.

The board deliberated for less than an hour, though to Frank, sitting in the hallway with Sadie and Hank and a paper cup of coffee gone cold in his hand, it felt longer. Mabel sat beside Lena, and the two of them did not talk much. Nakamura stood by the window, reading something on her phone, her face giving nothing away. When the clerk came out and asked them to return, Frank stood up slowly, feeling the stiffness in his knees, and Sadie took his arm without making a fuss about it, the way she had since she was small and he had taught her to walk beside a man rather than ahead of him.

The chair read the findings in the same plain voice she had used all day. The board found that Sierra Vista Motors had engaged in a pattern of diverting limited-allocation vehicles from its waitlisted retail customers to a broker, for undisclosed payments, and that its records had been altered to conceal the diversion. It found that the store's management, principally Steve Callahan, had directed the scheme, and that Colin Ashby had participated in it and had since cooperated fully and truthfully with the investigation. It ordered restitution for the skipped buyers, in the form of vehicles offered at the manufacturer's suggested retail price in waitlist order, and it ordered the store to post its waitlist publicly, to keep it in writing, and to submit to a compliance review in six months. It barred Troy Beckett and his company from doing business with the store, and from receiving any further allocation through it, and it referred the payment records to the state attorney general's office for whatever further action that office deemed appropriate.

News in the same category

Salesman Ordered an Older Customer Out—Then Learned Who Owned the Showroom

30 Part