She Was Shamed in Front of the Entire Board — The Billionaire Holding Their $2 Billion Lifeline Never Raised Her Voice

Chapter 15

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

What she did next she did in the order an audit committee chair does things, which is to say on paper and without telephone calls that could later be described as conversations. She convened the audit committee in writing for that afternoon — herself and the two other independent directors who served on it, the dairy cooperative woman and the retired banker, both of whom read the same memo in the same flat silence and asked the same first question, which was whether the general counsel would attend, and the second, which was the operative one: what did he know that the memo had not said. He attended. He said what he knew, in the order he had learned it: the index, the folder, the letter of intent, the store numbers laid beside the exhibit, the match. He had brought the documents — the actual documents, printed, because he was of the generation that believed a thing existed when it could be put on a table — and he put them on the table, and the committee read them in the silence that Faye Dunlop would later remember as the true beginning of the end of the old Fairbank Foods, a silence nothing like the boardroom's, being the silence of people reading to the bottom.

The committee's resolutions were adopted before the light failed. The audit committee would engage, at the company's expense and under its own direction, an outside law firm and a forensic accounting practice to review the circumstances of the letter of intent, the preparation of the draft certificate, and the board's and management's knowledge of each. The review would report to the committee, not to management. The company's officers were directed to preserve all documents, in terms that the outside firm drafted and that were broad enough to cover the future. The general counsel was thanked, in the minutes, for bringing the matter forward — a sentence Faye Dunlop insisted on, word by word, because she had decided that the record of this affair, unlike the record of the meeting, was going to show who had done their work and when. When the retired banker asked, quietly, whether the chairman had been informed, she said that the chairman would be informed by her, in the morning, in person, as a courtesy, and that the review would proceed regardless of his view of it, because it was not within the gift of the reviewed to review the review. She said it without pleasure. She had known Nate Fairbank since he was a boy photographed at store openings. She was godmother, in the loose Cincinnati sense, to half the christenings in his generation of the family. None of that appeared in the minutes either. The minutes said the committee had met, and considered a memorandum, and resolved. It was the first honest document the affair produced, and characteristically it was the one almost nobody would ever read.

Faye Dunlop informed the chairman in his office the following morning, in person, as promised, standing because she had not been asked to sit and because standing shortened things. She told him the audit committee had commissioned a review, its scope, and its reporting line, in the order of the resolutions. She did not show him the letter of intent; a review's subject is not given the exhibits as a courtesy. She watched him receive the news the way he had received most unwelcome news in his tenure, by translating it instantly into the dialect of his confidence, and she listened to the translation with the attention of a woman who had audited translations for a living.

It was a real-estate exploration, he said. Companies explored dispositions constantly; the property people ran scenarios the way the treasury ran forecasts; a letter of intent was not a plan, it was a conversation with a price on it, and if every conversation a company had were a representation waiting to be falsified, no company in America could sign a closing certificate. The review would find, he said, that the thing had never been approved, never been to the board, never risen above the level of an option the company was keeping warm against a future nobody had chosen. He said the word exploratory four times. He said that he regretted the committee had felt it necessary to proceed without discussing the context with him first, and she replied — in the flattest voice in her considerable register — that the context was what the review was for, and that she had come to tell him before the preservation letters went out, as a courtesy, and that the courtesy had now been extended.

News in the same category

She Was Shamed in Front of the Entire Board — The Billionaire Holding Their $2 Billion Lifeline Never Raised Her Voice

45 Part