A folded sheet at the back of the final ledger contained a list of five children and their destinations. Four names matched cases already under investigation. The fifth entry was different. It listed a girl under the initials L.M., with a note: retained locally, no agency record.
Ellison read it twice. “Someone kept this child close.”
“Who?”
The next page held a handwritten note: Evelyn has the girl. Hales says she must never be told.
Daniel looked at the line until the words blurred.
“Who was the girl?”
Ellison photographed the page. “We don't know yet.”
They searched the rest of the house. In a locked upstairs cupboard, the technician found a small box of personal items: a child’s red hair ribbon, a school photograph with the face scratched out, and a folded birthday card addressed to “Lily.” The card was signed with a single initial: E.
Daniel picked up the photograph, careful not to touch the image. The girl looked about six. She had dark hair, a narrow chin, and a small crescent-shaped mark at the base of her throat.
He looked at Ellison.
The mark was familiar. It was the same shape as the one on his own skin, and the one in the photograph of Miriam’s newborn.
“Could she be related to me?” he asked.
“We can’t know from a photograph,” Ellison said. “But we have a name and a possible link. We’ll find out who Lily is.”
Back at the house, Rebecca listened as Daniel described the discovery. She sat very still.
“Lily,” she repeated.
“Does the name mean something to you?”
Rebecca shook her head, then stopped. “Elaine had a photograph in her desk. A little girl with dark hair. I saw it once when I was looking for stamps. She snatched it away and told me it was none of my business.”
“Did you see the name?”
“No. But she said, ‘She should have been ours.’”
Daniel felt the words settle between them.
“Did she mean me?”
“I don't think so.”
Rebecca looked toward the stairs, where Sophie was reading. “I think she meant another child.”
That night, Daniel called Miriam. When he told her about Lily and the crescent-shaped birthmark, Miriam became silent.
“Peter mentioned a girl,” she said at last. “Not by name. He said there was a child who had been kept near the people who arranged the placements. He thought she might be the reason Hales kept the duplicate register.”
“Do you know who her mother was?”
“No. Peter said he was trying to find out. He told me he thought the girl had been raised by someone who was not her legal guardian.”
Daniel looked at the photograph again.
“Could she be alive?”
“I hope so,” Miriam said. “But Daniel, if she is, we must be careful. She may not know any of this. She may believe the people who raised her are her parents.”
He thought of Jane Ralston, sitting beside the music box, listening to a stranger describe the mother she had never known. He thought of Sophie, upstairs, safe in her own room.
“Then we tell her carefully,” he said.
Miriam’s voice was gentle. “Yes. Carefully, and with the truth.”
The next morning, Ellison called with a name. The child in the photograph had been registered as Lily Mercer. The record listed Elaine and Thomas Mercer as her guardians for a period of fourteen months, beginning when she was six months old.
Daniel stared at the phone.
“Lily Mercer?” he said.
“Yes,” Ellison replied. “And the record says she was transferred to a family in Vermont. We’re trying to locate her.”
Daniel looked across the kitchen at Rebecca. She had heard the name. Her face had gone pale.
“Elaine had her,” Rebecca whispered. “For more than a year.”
The house seemed to close around them again. Daniel had believed the secret was about the child he had been. Now he was beginning to understand that the people who raised him had once been given another child, too.
And this time, the name on the file belonged to someone who might still be alive.
The first lead on Lily came from a school enrollment form in Vermont. The child had been registered as Lily Mercer, then as Lily Cross, and finally as Lily Avery. Each change had occurred within a year. The last record showed her living with a couple named Ruth and Samuel Avery in a small town near the Green Mountains.
Samuel Avery had died twelve years earlier. Ruth was alive, eighty-seven, and living in an assisted-living residence. She had no children listed as next of kin.
Ellison made the call herself. She explained that the department was reviewing records from St. Catherine’s and that Lily’s name had appeared in documents connected to a historical investigation. Ruth listened without interruption.
“I wondered when someone would come,” she said.
Ellison glanced at Daniel. “You knew about the records?”
“I knew there were papers. I knew the people who brought her to us were not telling the whole truth. I didn't know where the child had come from.”