The House Behind the Wall That Nobody Dares to Enter

Chapter 39

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Daniel considered the question. “I don't know yet. Some days I want to call her. Some days I don't want to hear her voice. Both feelings are true.”

Claire nodded. “That's probably where I am.”

“Then you don't have to decide today.”

“I know.” She looked through the glass at Margaret, who was still seated at the table, reading the letter again. “I want to see her next week. Somewhere quieter. Maybe outside.”

“I think she'd like that.”

“Don't tell her I said that yet.”

“I won't.”

Claire started toward the exit, then turned back. “Did they ever find out who did it?”

“Some of them. Not all.”

“Does that mean they're going to get away with it?”

“No,” Daniel said. He wished he could promise more. “It means we're still finding out what accountability looks like.”

Ellison had been listening without appearing to. She stepped forward only after Claire had left. “That was more than most people manage on a first meeting,” she said.

“It wasn't much,” Daniel replied.

“It was honest. Sometimes that's the only thing that can happen first.”

The investigation had meanwhile reached a point where the old files were no longer enough. Ellison's team had traced payments from St. Catherine's through two charitable foundations and a law office that had dissolved in the late nineties. The names on the documents were familiar: Hales, Reddick, and a physician named Dr. Leonard Voss. Voss had died twelve years earlier. His daughter, Ellen, lived in Saratoga Springs and had kept his papers after his death, believing them to be ordinary professional records.

When Ellison called, Ellen Voss did not deny that her father had worked with St. Catherine's. She did, however, ask whether the call concerned the children.

It did.

“I wondered when somebody would come,” she said.

She agreed to meet them at her home. The house was neat, modest, and crowded with books. Ellen was in her late fifties, with her father's careful manner but none of his practiced certainty. She brought a cardboard archive box from a closet and set it on the dining table.

“My father kept things he shouldn't have,” she said. “I knew that much. He told me it was because people lied about him. I didn't know what the papers meant until I started reading them after he died.”

Inside were appointment books, carbon copies of letters, and a small envelope marked with a date from 1992. Ellen had written nothing on it. She said it had been sealed when she found it.

Ellison put on gloves before opening it. The envelope contained a list of six names, each followed by a date, a hospital reference, and a payment amount. Three names matched children already identified. One matched Lucy's case. Another was Anna Bell. The final name was unfamiliar: Evelyn Price.

Beside Evelyn's name was a note in Voss's handwriting: “Mother objected. Hales says family will accept explanation. Do not use ward ledger.”

“Who was Evelyn Price?” Daniel asked.

Ellen shook her head. “I don't know. But I remember the name. My father used to say that one case had gone wrong because the mother wouldn't cooperate.”

Ellison photographed the page. “Did he ever say what happened to her?”

“He said she was difficult. That was his word for women who asked questions.”

There was a second paper beneath the list: a letter from Voss to Hales, dated three days later. It said the mother had refused to sign the release and had threatened to contact the state. Voss wrote that he would not participate in another transfer without a signed order. Hales replied in the margin, in a different pen: “Then don't participate. We have other channels.”

A third document, folded into quarters, was a copy of a birth registration. The child was recorded as female, born at St. Catherine's on the date listed beside Evelyn's name. The space for the mother's signature was blank. In the lower corner, someone had typed a destination: “Temporary placement, Mercer residence.”

Daniel felt the room tilt, though he remained standing.

“Mercer?” he said.

Ellen looked at him. “Your family?”

Ellison took the paper and examined it closely. “This could be a reference to Elaine and Thomas. It doesn't prove the child stayed with them.”

But Daniel had already remembered the photograph in Hales's aunt's house: the little girl with the crescent-shaped mark near her ear, the red ribbon in her hair. The note had called her “our little guest.” They had believed that child was Lucy. Now the documents suggested there might have been another girl, or that the same child had been moved through the Mercer home under a different name.

“Could the list be incomplete?” he asked.

“Almost certainly,” Ellison said. “It says six, but we have reason to believe there were more.”

Ellen touched the edge of the letter. “My father told me once that he had tried to stop it. I believed him because I wanted to. But this says he knew a mother had refused, and he kept working with Hales afterward.”

News in the same category

The House Behind the Wall That Nobody Dares to Enter

45 Part