They talked about the Averys. Lily described Ruth's garden, Samuel's habit of repairing things that were not broken, and the way they never asked her to call them anything other than Mom and Dad. She loved them. She did not want the truth about her birth to turn their love into a lie.
“It doesn't have to,” Daniel said. “My parents loved me too. What they did with the truth was wrong. But the love was real.”
“That's a difficult thing to hold.”
“I know.”
Lily studied him. “Are you angry with them?”
“Sometimes. Sometimes I'm angry with myself for being angry. Mostly I'm trying to stop turning every memory into evidence.”
She smiled faintly. “That sounds exhausting.”
“It is.”
After an hour, Daniel gave her Sophie's drawing. Lily unfolded it and looked at the three figures in front of the house.
“There's room,” she read.
“She made it for you.”
Lily traced the letters with one finger. Her eyes filled, but she kept her voice steady. “Tell her thank you.”
“Would you like to meet her?”
“Not today. But yes. I think I would.”
Before they left, Lily asked whether Daniel would tell Miriam that she was willing to speak. He said he would. Then she reached across the table and touched his wrist.
“I don't know how to be your sister,” she said.
“Neither do I.”
“Maybe we can learn.”
He turned his hand and let her hold it.
On the drive home, Daniel called Miriam from a roadside rest area. She answered immediately.
“How was she?”
“She’s wonderful. And she wants to talk to you.”
Miriam began to cry. Daniel could hear her trying to steady her breathing.
“Did she ask about me?”
“She asked whether you were alive. She asked what happened. She said she wants to speak.”
“Then I will wait until she is ready.”
“She is ready to talk. Not necessarily ready for everything.”
“I understand.”
Daniel paused. “She loves the Averys. She doesn't want anyone to think they weren't her parents.”
“They were her parents in the ways that mattered every day,” Miriam said. “I don't need to take that from her.”
That evening, Miriam and Lily spoke by video call. Daniel stayed nearby but out of frame. The first few minutes were awkward. Miriam kept her hands folded, as if she were afraid that reaching toward the screen might frighten Lily away.
“You look like your father,” Miriam said at last.
“Which father?” Lily asked, then immediately looked embarrassed.
Miriam smiled gently. “The man who raised you, I suppose. I don't know your birth father. I only know the little girl I held in the hospital.”
Lily asked what she had been like as a baby. Miriam described her dark hair, the way she curled her fingers around a blanket, and how she had cried whenever the room grew quiet.
“Did you sing to me?” Lily asked.
“I did. I sang the same little tune I sang to Daniel when he was a baby.”
“Do you remember it?”
Miriam hummed four notes. Lily opened the music box she had brought from Ruth's house. The same broken melody came out, faltering at the fourth note.
Miriam covered her mouth.
“Anna used to hum that,” she whispered. “She taught it to me at St. Catherine’s.”
Lily looked at the box. “Ruth said it belonged to my birth mother.”
“It may have belonged to Anna,” Miriam said. “I don't know how it came to you.”
For a while they sat with the sound of the music box between them. Then Lily asked the question she had been carrying.
“Why didn't you come for me?”
Miriam did not look away. “I tried. I was ill after you were born, and I asked Elaine to care for you until I could stand on my own. I thought she would bring you back. Then Hales threatened to have you taken permanently and to use what he knew about Daniel against me. Elaine moved you. She told me you were safe, but she would not tell me where. I should have fought harder. I should have found another way. I am sorry.”
Lily listened without interrupting.
“Were you afraid?” she asked.
“Yes.”
“Were you ashamed?”
Miriam took a breath. “Sometimes. But I was never ashamed of you.”
Lily's eyes filled. “I don't know what I feel yet.”
“You don't have to know today.”
“I want to talk again.”
“I would like that.”
When the call ended, Miriam sat very still. Daniel came into the room and placed a glass of water beside her.
“She has my voice,” Miriam said.
“She has her own voice too.”
Miriam nodded. “Yes. She does.”
The next development came from Ellison. The original records recovered from Millhaven had been matched against four known cases, but the fifth child, listed as L.M., had been moved through a separate arrangement. The initials did not refer to Lily Mercer, as they had first assumed. Lily's file was recorded elsewhere. The fifth entry described a girl who had been retained locally and never formally adopted.