The House Behind the Wall That Nobody Dares to Enter

Chapter 42

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

“My husband kept a Bible,” she said. “He wrote things in it. Dates, names. He thought it was important to remember who came through here.”

The niece went upstairs and returned with a large black Bible wrapped in a pillowcase. Its pages were brittle, but a few entries near the back had been made in pencil. One read: “Emily, from St. Catherine's, arrived May 11. Taken by Mr. Bennett, June 2. Mother asking again. Told no contact.”

The last phrase had been crossed out so heavily the paper was almost torn.

June began to cry, quietly and without any visible change in her expression. “I was told the mother was unstable. I believed them. I held that baby every night for three weeks. I should have asked more questions.”

Ellison placed a tissue box within reach. “You can tell us what you remember now. That's what matters.”

On the drive back, Daniel called Rebecca and told her about the Bible. She listened without interrupting.

“I remember the girl in the bedroom,” she said when he finished. “But I also remember a baby carrier by the kitchen door. Elaine told me not to touch it. I thought it belonged to someone visiting.”

“Could it have been Evelyn's baby?”

“I don't know. It could have been. I should have asked.”

“We're all saying that.”

“Maybe that's what this is,” Rebecca said. “A whole chain of people who saw one thing that didn't make sense and decided somebody else must understand it.”

Daniel looked at the road. “We can't change what we didn't ask then. We can answer now.”

The Vermont lead took another week to verify. A county clerk located an adoption petition filed under the name Emily Mercer, with a later amendment changing the child's surname to Bennett. The adoptive parents had since died. Their daughter, now forty-two, lived in Burlington and worked as a speech therapist. Her name was Emily Bennett.

She agreed to speak with Ellison by video call but declined to meet Daniel. Her first question was whether the investigation meant her parents had done something wrong.

“We don't know that,” Ellison told her. “The records suggest the placement may have been made without your birth mother's consent. That doesn't tell us what your adoptive parents knew.”

Emily listened, her hands folded on the desk. “They told me I was adopted. They said my birth mother was young and couldn't care for me. I never had a reason to doubt them.”

“Did you ever see your original records?”

“No. My mother said they were sealed. She had a folder, though. She kept it in a drawer with my baby teeth and school certificates.”

“Would you be willing to look for it?”

Emily hesitated. “I can. But I need to understand something. Is someone claiming I'm supposed to go back to a family I don't know?”

“No,” Ellison said. “No one is asking that. We're trying to establish what happened and give you accurate information. What you do with it is your decision.”

After the call, Emily sent a photograph of the folder. It contained a baptism certificate, a vaccination card, and a letter from her adoptive mother. The letter said that Emily had come to them through a private placement arranged by a physician. It also said the birth mother had asked that the child be told she was loved, but the agency had advised the adoptive parents not to mention the request because it might complicate bonding.

Emily called again that evening.

“I read the letter,” she said. “My mother wrote that she thought it was cruel to keep the message from me, but she was afraid the agency would take me back if she asked too many questions.”

Daniel was beside Ellison when the call came through. He recognized the shape of the fear. It had been handed from one adult to another until it looked like a reason.

“Do you want to know your birth mother's name?” Ellison asked.

“Yes,” Emily said. “And whether she's alive.”

The name was Evelyn Price. The state records showed that she had married, moved twice, and died in 2018. Her obituary listed two sons and a daughter, but the daughter was named as a niece who had been raised in the family. Ellison began tracing that line through public records. The daughter, Nora Price, was alive and living in western Massachusetts.

When Nora answered the phone, she was silent for several seconds after hearing the name St. Catherine's.

“My mother used to talk about a baby,” she said. “Not often. She'd say she had a daughter somewhere, and then she'd stop. My father told us she had been sick after the birth and had imagined it. I thought it was something she couldn't bear to remember.”

“Did she ever tell you the baby's name?” Ellison asked.

“She called her Emily. She kept a birthday card in her dresser, never addressed. Every year she wrote the date on it and put it away again.”

News in the same category

The House Behind the Wall That Nobody Dares to Enter

45 Part