On Sunday morning, he sat on the front porch with his phone in his hand. Rebecca stayed inside with Sophie, giving him privacy. At ten past eleven, the phone rang.
“Hello?” he said.
A woman’s voice answered. “My name is Lily. I think you might be my brother.”
Daniel looked across the yard at the house. The walls were quiet. The front door stood open behind him.
“I think you might be,” he said.
And for the first time, the secret behind the wall had a voice that was not asking to be let in. It was asking whether there was room to begin again.
Lily called again on Wednesday evening. This time, Daniel was ready with a notebook, though he quickly realized there was no sensible way to prepare for a conversation with a sister he had not known existed until a week earlier.
“I'm sorry I didn't call sooner,” she said. Her voice was low and measured, with the faint salt-air rasp of someone who spent much of her day outdoors. “I read your letter several times. I kept thinking there had to be some mistake.”
“I understand.”
“Do you? Because I don't. I don't know whether I'm angry, relieved, frightened, or all three.”
“Probably all three,” Daniel said. “That's where I've been.”
She laughed once, without much humor. “You sound like a brother already.”
They spoke for nearly an hour. Lily told him that the Averys had been kind, but that she had always felt something was missing from the story of her adoption. Ruth had told her, when she was sixteen, that she had not been their biological child and that the circumstances were complicated. She had given Lily the name on the hospital bracelet, Lily Vale, but refused to say more.
“I left when I was eighteen because I thought I could find the answer myself,” Lily said. “I wrote to the agency. They told me the records were sealed. I contacted a lawyer, but he said there was nothing to challenge. Eventually I stopped asking. I thought maybe the people who knew were dead.”
“Some are,” Daniel said. “Some aren't.”
“Is Miriam alive?”
“Yes.”
Lily was silent. “Does she want to meet me?”
“She does. But she told me to make sure you know you don't owe her anything.”
“That sounds like something a mother would say.”
Daniel looked toward the kitchen, where Rebecca was helping Sophie with homework. “She has been careful not to ask for more than you're ready to give.”
“I want to see you first,” Lily said. “I need to know what you’re like before I decide what to do about the rest.”
“That's fair.”
They agreed to meet in a public place the following weekend. Lily chose a small café near the harbor in Harrow Point. She did not want a crowd, but she did not want to meet at home either. Daniel agreed. He asked whether she wanted Rebecca there, and Lily said no. She wanted to meet her brother alone.
On Saturday morning, Daniel drove north with a small overnight bag. He told Sophie he was going to meet someone important. She asked if it was Miriam. When he said it was his sister, she blinked.
“You have a sister?”
“I do.”
“Is she like me?”
“I don't know yet.”
Sophie considered this. “Maybe she likes pancakes.”
“I'll ask.”
She handed him a folded drawing. It showed three people standing in front of a house: Daniel, Sophie, and a woman with dark hair. Above them, Sophie had written, THERE IS ROOM.
“Give it to her,” she said.
The café was warm and crowded with the smell of coffee and wet wool. Lily was sitting at a table by the window. She stood when Daniel entered. She was a little shorter than him, with dark hair tied loosely at the back and a crescent-shaped birthmark just below her throat.
For a moment they simply looked at each other.
“You have it too,” she said, touching the mark.
Daniel nodded. “So do you.”
“I used to think it was a stain. Ruth said it was a family mark, though she didn't know why.”
They sat. Lily ordered tea. Daniel ordered coffee and forgot to drink it.
She asked about the passage in the house, and he told her about Sophie hearing someone behind the wall, the hidden room, and the woman in the blue sweater. He did not describe every detail. He wanted Lily to understand that the story was frightening, but not to feel that she had been brought into it as another mystery to solve.
“Did Miriam live in the wall?” Lily asked.
“She used the passage to get into the house. She wasn't there all the time. She was trying to see me.”
Lily looked down. “She must have been desperate.”
“She was. And she made choices that frightened Sophie. She knows that.”
“I don't blame her for wanting to see you.”
“Neither do I. I just wish she'd found another way.”
Lily nodded. “I think I understand that.”