The House Behind the Wall That Nobody Dares to Enter

Chapter 34

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Margaret shook her head. “I thought she was with the Mercers until she was old enough to be adopted. I thought Elaine would tell me when it happened.”

“She may have been moved to another family,” Ellison said. “We are trying to trace the records.”

Margaret looked at Daniel. “Did Elaine tell you about her?”

“No.”

“Did she tell you she had kept a little girl in your house?”

“No.”

Margaret closed her eyes. “Then she kept that secret too.”

On the drive back, Daniel asked Ellison whether Margaret could be reunited with Lucy.

“If we can find her, we can give her the choice,” Ellison said. “But Lucy may have been raised under another name. She may not know any of this.”

“Like Lily.”

“Yes. But this case is different. Lucy was never formally adopted, at least not in the records we have. That means someone may have created an identity for her outside the legal system.”

They returned to Millhaven and searched the remaining documents from Hales’s aunt’s house. In a ledger tucked beneath the bottom drawer, they found a list of temporary addresses. One entry read: L.M. — Mercer residence — 14 months. Another, written later, read: M. Lane — contact terminated. A third line contained a name Daniel had not seen before: Grace Holloway.

Ellison looked at the entry. “This may be the person who took Lucy after the Mercers.”

A separate file contained a school enrollment form for a girl named Grace Holloway, age six, living at an address in Albany. The parent or guardian line had been left blank. The emergency contact was Victor Hales.

Daniel stared at the form. “Why would Hales be the emergency contact?”

“Because he was controlling the placement,” Ellison said.

The address belonged to a building that had been demolished years earlier. The school had closed. The records had been transferred to a district archive, but the name Grace Holloway did not appear in later enrollment files.

There was, however, a withdrawal form. The reason given was “family relocation.” The destination field was empty.

Ellison requested the original file. While they waited, Nora called with news about the recovered ledgers. A handwriting expert had compared the signatures on the temporary placements with those on the altered consent forms. Several signatures attributed to mothers were likely written by the same person.

“Hales?” Daniel asked.

“Possibly. The expert won't identify him without a direct comparison. But there is one signature that appears on nearly every document. E. Cross.”

“Evelyn?”

“Yes. She signed as caseworker, witness, and in some cases as the person receiving the child.”

Daniel remembered Marianne’s account. Evelyn had visited the house. She had promised Margaret that Lucy would be safe. She had also signed the papers that kept the girl from her mother.

The next afternoon, Marianne Cross called Ellison. She had found a second envelope among her mother's belongings. It contained a note addressed to Margaret Lane.

I have done something I cannot undo. The child is safe, but she is no longer where you believe. I was told the move was necessary. I was told her mother would be allowed to see her later. I don't believe that now. If you can find the girl, do not let Hales know. He has a copy of every file, and he has used them to frighten the people who signed.

The note was dated 1993, and signed by Evelyn.

On the reverse was a telephone number, crossed out twice, and a final line: Ask for Grace. She knows the girl’s real name.

Daniel read the sentence aloud.

“Grace knows Lucy’s real name,” Ellison said.

“And Hales knows where she is,” Daniel replied.

Ellison folded the note into an evidence sleeve. “Then we need to find Grace before he does.”

That evening, Daniel told Rebecca what they had learned. She listened, then went to the attic and returned with the suitcase. She placed the small shoes on the table.

“I remember Lucy wearing these,” she said. “I remember her standing in the kitchen while Elaine made toast. She called her Grandma. Elaine told her not to say that outside the house.”

“Did she ever call you anything?”

Rebecca nodded. “She called me Becky. She used to sit beside me while I folded laundry. I thought she was a neighbor’s child who had been left with Elaine for a few days.”

“Did you ever ask her where her mother was?”

“Once. She said her mother was coming when she got better.”

Rebecca’s voice broke. “I told her that was good.”

Daniel looked at the little shoes. He imagined a child waiting in the kitchen, believing that a mother would come through the front door one day. He imagined Elaine telling her to use a different name outside the house. He imagined Margaret writing letters that came back unopened.

“Did Elaine ever tell you why Lucy left?” he asked.

“She said the placement had changed. She said it was safer that way.”

“Safer for whom?”

Rebecca did not answer.

News in the same category

The House Behind the Wall That Nobody Dares to Enter

45 Part