“Then who is L.M.?” Daniel asked.
“We're checking a second set of names from the old hospital register,” Ellison said. “But there's another problem. Hales has left his residence.”
“Where did he go?”
“His lawyer says he is receiving treatment at a private clinic. The clinic has no record of him being admitted.”
Daniel felt the old unease return. “Do you think he's running?”
“I think he knows we're close to identifying the people who helped him.”
That night, Rebecca told Daniel something she had not mentioned before. In the year before Elaine died, she had found a small suitcase in the attic. It contained children's clothes, a faded blue sweater, and a paper tag with the name L.M. Elaine had taken the suitcase from her and said it belonged to a child who had once stayed with them.
“Why didn't you tell me then?” Daniel asked.
“I thought it was Lily's. I thought the initials meant her. I didn't understand there was another child.”
“Where is the suitcase?”
“I put it back in the attic. I don't know whether it's still there.”
They searched the attic after Sophie went to bed. The suitcase was still behind the old holiday decorations. Inside were two dresses, a pair of small shoes, and a photograph of a girl standing in front of the house. She was about four years old. Her hair was light, not dark like Lily's. A crescent-shaped birthmark showed at the base of her throat.
On the back of the photograph, Elaine had written: Our little guest. Spring, 1992.
Daniel stared at the picture.
The girl had lived in their house. Not as a baby, not as a brief visitor. The clothes were worn, the shoes repaired, and one dress had a name stitched into the collar: Lucy.
“L.M.,” Rebecca whispered. “Lucy Mercer?”
Daniel looked at her. “Was she ever here when I was a child?”
“I don't remember. You were older than her by several years. Maybe she was here before Sophie was born.”
The house had given up another name. And this time, the child in the photograph had not been sent to a distant family. She had been kept close enough to leave her shoes in the attic.
Ellison arrived the next morning to examine the suitcase. The photograph, clothing, and tag were logged as evidence. She asked Rebecca to describe everything she remembered about the child.
“She was quiet,” Rebecca said. “I remember a little girl sitting on the back steps with Elaine. I thought she was a neighbor's child. She called Elaine ‘Grandma’ once. Elaine corrected her and said, ‘Not here.’”
Daniel felt a cold line run down his back.
“Not here?”
Rebecca nodded. “I thought it was a game. I didn't ask.”
Ellison looked at the photograph again. “We need to identify Lucy. If she was kept in this house, there may be more records.”
Daniel looked toward the repaired wall. For weeks, he had thought the passage was the secret. Now he understood it had only been a hiding place. The real secret was the number of people who had been brought into the house, given temporary names, and then sent away before anyone could ask why.
And somewhere, Lucy was still waiting to be found.
Ellison found the name Lucy in an old county guardianship index. The entry was brief: Lucy May, temporary ward, transferred from St. Catherine’s, placed with Thomas and Elaine Mercer for a period not exceeding ninety days. The file had been closed without a final disposition. No adoption petition, no transfer order, no record of a family receiving her afterward.
“Someone forgot to finish the paperwork,” Daniel said.
“Or someone made sure there would be no paperwork to finish,” Ellison replied.
The index listed a caseworker named Evelyn Cross. She had signed the placement form and the final review, though the signatures were separated by fourteen months. Ellison searched the state employment records and found that Cross had left the agency in 1993. She had moved to a small town in western Massachusetts and died six years earlier.
Her daughter, however, was alive. Her name was Marianne Cross, and she had inherited a box of her mother’s professional records. When Ellison called, Marianne said she remembered Lucy.
“She was with us for a while,” Marianne said. “Not in our home. At the Mercer house. My mother used to visit. She said the little girl was waiting for her mother to get well.”
“Did your mother say who the mother was?”
“No. But she used to call her ‘the girl from the maternity ward.’ She said the child had been placed temporarily, and that the paperwork had become complicated.”
“Did your mother ever bring Lucy back?”
Marianne hesitated. “No. She said the Mercers had agreed to keep her until a safe placement could be found. Then she stopped talking about it.”
Ellison asked whether Marianne still had the records.
“I have a box,” she said. “But there’s something else. When my mother was dying, she told me that if anyone ever asked about Lucy, I should give them a photograph and a name. She said the child’s mother had never stopped looking.”