On Saturday, a week after the tow truck, George Thompson knocked on our front door in the late morning. He was carrying a small paper bag, and inside it was a thumb drive. "Sophie sent me a copy of the video," he said, "and I put it on this for safekeeping. I have one at my house too, and Alice has one. If anything happens to a phone, we've still got it. That's how you keep evidence, Frank. You keep it in more than one place, and you keep it with people you trust."
On Sunday, Miguel Santos came over to talk about the camera. "I've been thinking about that camera," Miguel said, standing in the driveway and looking up at the eave. "If Marty comes back, or if Jake comes back at night, you want that camera to catch it clean, with a date and a time on it, and you want it to keep recording even if someone unplugs something. Let me check it this week, before your lawyer meeting if I can, so you know exactly what you've got."
Monday evening came, and with it, another letter from Marty, slipped into the mailbox late in the afternoon. This one was different in tone. It was shorter, and colder, and it said the board would consider the matter at its next regular meeting, and that I would be given an opportunity to be heard, subject to the board's rules of order. Helen read it aloud at the dinner table, and then she folded it and filed it, and she said, "He's inviting you to a meeting where he controls the microphone. That's not a hearing, Frank. That's a stage."
She was right, and we both knew it, but we also knew we had to go. A man who does not show up to his own hearing, even a hearing run by a man who has already made up his mind, gives that man something to point to later. So we decided, that night, that we would go to the meeting, that we would bring the folder, that we would speak calmly and briefly, and that we would let Marty show the room who he was, if that was what he intended to do. Olivia Grant's appointment was still a day away, and we did not want to wait for permission to defend ourselves in our own neighbourhood. We would go, and we would listen, and we would remember everything, and Helen would write it down afterward, the way she wrote everything down, in pencil, on the back of the meeting notice.
Tuesday morning, we drove to Olivia Grant's office in Knoxville, carrying the Mustang folder in a canvas tote bag, along with a second folder Helen had made that morning, labelled in her neat hand, with copies of the most important letters and a one-page timeline she had typed up the night before. The timeline was simple: the date of the first rule letter, the date of the first fine, the date of my reply asking for the rule and the vote record, the date of each subsequent fine, and the date of the Saturday confrontation. It fit on one page, and it told the story without exaggeration, which was exactly what Helen intended. A timeline does not shout. It just sits there, in order, and dares anyone to argue with the dates.
Olivia Grant's office was on the second floor of a brick building near the courthouse, with a waiting room that had plain chairs and a coffee machine and no fancy art on the walls. Olivia herself was a woman in her late forties, with short dark hair and a direct way of looking at you when you spoke, as if she were listening for the facts underneath the feelings. She shook our hands, offered us coffee, and then she opened the folder and started reading, not skimming, but reading, page by page, making small notes in the margin of her own notepad as she went. She did not interrupt, and she did not reassure us before she had finished. She read the first letter, and the reply, and the fine letters, and the daily fine letters, and the meeting notice, and then she looked up.
"Mr. Delaney," she said, "Mrs. Delaney, I want to be plain with you, because plain is what you need right now. First, do not pay these fines. Not a dollar, not yet. Paying does not make this go away, and it can be read later as if you accepted the rule. Second, do not move the car. It is registered, it is insured, it is on your own driveway, and moving it now would look like you agreed it did not belong there. Third, keep doing exactly what you are doing. Keep every envelope. Keep the date you received it. Keep copies of everything you send, and send it in a way you can prove, by certified mail or by email with a receipt, not just by dropping it in a box."