Brenda Sandoval was sentenced next. She was sixty-three, and she had signed cheques without reading the backup, year after year, and the court had to decide what to do with a woman who had not invented the scheme but had kept it alive with her signature. Judge Vance was careful with her, and also firm. Brenda received two years suspended, which meant she would not go to prison if she kept to the terms the court set, and she was placed on probation with conditions that included three hundred hours of community service. Three hundred hours. I did the arithmetic in my head without meaning to, the way a mechanic counts bolts: that was weeks of work, real work, not a fine she could write a cheque for and forget. The judge said the community service would be served with organisations approved by the court, not with the HOA, and that Brenda would also be required to complete a financial accountability course and to make her own restitution payments on the schedule set for her. Brenda cried quietly when the sentence was read, not loudly, and her hands shook as she held a tissue. I felt no triumph watching her. I felt tired, and I felt sorry for the waste of it, because Brenda had once been a careful woman who kept good garden records and brought soup to new neighbours, and somewhere along the way she had traded that care for the ease of signing where Marty pointed.
Jake Moran came after her. He was forty-nine, broad-shouldered, a man used to being the biggest presence in a driveway, and in the courtroom he looked smaller, the way all of us look smaller in a room built for judgment. He had pleaded to his part in the tow and storage scheme, the inflated rates, the eighty-five dollars a day that had piled up like interest on a debt nobody owed. Judge Vance sentenced him to eighteen months suspended, with probation, and she took his tow licence for three years. Three years without the work he had built his business on. She also ordered him to repay the storage fees he had collected under the scheme, every dollar of it, on the same court-supervised schedule. Jake nodded as each condition was read, and he did not argue, and he did not look at Marty, who was already gone. Later, outside, Olivia told me that losing the licence was the part that had frightened him most, more than the suspended sentence, because a suspended sentence is a warning and a lost licence is a living. I believed her. A man can sit with a warning. He cannot tow a car without a licence, and for three years, Jake Moran would have to find another way to earn, or sit with what the old way had cost him.
Tyler Cole was handled separately, as Olivia had said he would be, because his case concerned the rigged lien plan and the dealership, River City Classics, and the court wanted his part kept clean and distinct from his uncle's. Tyler was thirty-four, and he stood in front of the judge in a suit that looked new and uncomfortable, and he listened while ADA Reed described the plan in plain terms: a car towed on a false order, stored at an inflated rate, and sold at a sale rigged so the dealership could buy it cheap and sell it on. My Mustang. My father's car, in a plan spoken aloud in a courtroom as if it were a business proposal. Hearing it said that way, without euphemism, made my hands tighten on the rail in front of me, and Helen put her hand over mine again, and I loosened my grip.
Tyler took a plea as well. He was sentenced to probation, with conditions, and he was banned from HOA contracts, not for a season but as a standing bar, so that no association in the county could hire his dealership for tow or lien or storage work under the arrangement he had tried to build. The judge said the ban was about trust as much as punishment, because a man who had tried to rig a sale could not be trusted to run a fair one for other people's homes. Tyler said he understood. He did not look at me, and I did not look for him to. Some apologies are owed, and some are simply not mine to collect.
When the last sentence was read and the courtroom began to empty, Olivia Grant found us in the hallway and walked us through what would happen next, because a sentence is not the same as money in hand, and she wanted us to understand the difference. The restitution would come in payments, she said, tracked by the court, with priority given to the households that had paid fines and to the association's reserve, and my eleven thousand two hundred dollars would be returned in full, with the first portion arriving within weeks and the rest on the schedule the judge had set. She said to keep every letter, to keep every receipt, to call her if a payment was late by even a day. Helen, who keeps every letter in labelled folders, smiled at that, a small tired smile, and said she would keep them in a new folder, and Olivia laughed, a short real laugh, and said that was exactly right.