Helen started a new folder that week, and she labelled it, in her neat hand, with a title that was simple and factual. Inside, she put copies, not originals, because she was careful about other people's papers, of each neighbour's letter, with the neighbour's name and address written in pencil on the back, and the date they had received it, and a short note about what the fine was for. She did not ask anyone to sign anything. She did not promise anyone anything. She just collected, and compared, and laid the letters out on the table in rows, the way a librarian lays out books to see which ones belong together. And as the rows grew, a pattern grew with them, clear enough that even I, who am not a lawyer and not a librarian, could see it. The letters were not isolated mistakes. They were a system, repeated, house after house, with the same wording, the same escalation, and the same missing paperwork.
Paul, when he saw the growing folder, said what we were all starting to think but had not yet said aloud. "Dad, if Marty is doing this to you, and to the Santoses, and to the fence lady, and to Harold, then he's not just picking on one driveway. He's running something. And if he's running something, then Olivia needs to see this folder too, not just yours."
On Monday evening, Miguel came back, as he had promised, with his ladder and his tester and his toolbox. The evening was warm, and the light was golden on the oaks, and the cul-de-sac was quiet in the way it is on a summer evening when people are cooking dinner and children are still playing in yards. Miguel set his ladder against the eave above the garage, climbed up with his tester in his pocket, and opened the small housing where the driveway camera sat. He checked the wire where it entered the garage, and he checked the connection at the monitor, and he checked the memory card, and he took his time, the way a good electrician does, not rushing, not assuming, testing each part before he moved to the next.
"It's working," he said after a while, climbing down and wiping his hands on a rag. "The picture is clear, day and night, and the date and time stamp is right. But the wire here, where it goes through the wall, it's a little loose, and if someone tugged it, or if a storm pulled it, you could lose a night's recording without knowing it until it was too late. Let me tighten that up, and let me show you how to check the card yourself, so you know every morning whether it recorded or not."
He worked for another half hour, tightening the connection, securing the wire with new clips, testing the night vision by covering the sensor with his hand and watching the image switch, and showing me, step by step, how to pull the card and check it on the computer in my study. When he finished, he stepped back into the driveway and looked up at the camera, and then at the Mustang, and then at me.
"There," he said. "Now it's solid. If anyone comes up this driveway again, day or night, you'll have it, with a time on it, and nobody will be able to say it didn't happen, or that it happened differently. That's what you need now, Frank. Not just a good car, and not just a good lawyer. You need a record that can't be argued with."
I stood in the driveway with Miguel as the evening light faded, and I looked up at the small red light on the camera, blinking steadily under the eave. The Mustang was beside me, locked, its green paint darkening in the dusk, its shape familiar and solid after all these years. Helen came out onto the porch with two glasses of iced tea, and she handed one to Miguel and one to me, and we stood there for a while, drinking, not talking much, just watching the street settle for the night. Somewhere down the cul-de-sac, a screen door closed. Somewhere else, a dog barked once and then stopped. The camera kept blinking, quiet and steady, and I thought about the folder on the dining room table, and about Olivia Grant's letter on its way to the board, and about the neighbours who had started to compare their fines, and about the meeting where Marty had cut me off, and I knew, without needing anyone to tell me, that the next step would not come from Marty. It would come from us, from the paper Helen had kept, and from the record Miguel had just made sure would hold.