That evening George Thompson came across the street to our porch, as he had done on the morning of the confrontation, and he sat with me while Helen made tea inside. George did not waste words. He said he had heard from Kim's office, and that he had brought in his own fine letter, the one for the trailer he did not own, and that Alice had found two more letters in a drawer that George had forgotten he had kept. He said the audit was the right thing, and that a neighbourhood could not heal until it knew the full extent of what had been done to it. I told him about the logbook, and about my car sitting in it on paper while it sat in my driveway in fact, and George shook his head slowly, the way a man shakes his head when he has seen a lot in his years as a deputy and still finds something that surprises him. He said a logbook was a man's word in writing, and that Jake had spent his word carelessly. Then he stayed for tea, and we talked about ordinary things, about the weather and the oaks and Sophie's schoolwork, and for a little while the audit felt like something happening at a distance, not in the middle of our street.
But the audit was not at a distance, and the next part of it came to our own door. Kim called us two days later and said she wanted to walk the neighbourhood with us, house by house, to confirm the twelve households and to make sure no household had been missed. We walked with her in the early evening, when the light was soft and people were coming home from work, and at each house Kim asked the same gentle questions: had they received a fine they did not understand, had they paid it, had they kept the letter, had they ever been threatened with a tow? At the Bennetts' house, the answer was a shed fine and a threat about a trailer. At the Whitakers', a boat fine and a storage bill for a boat that had never left their yard. At the Lawsons', a fence fine that had doubled when they questioned it. At the Doyles', a fine for a work truck that belonged to a son who had moved away years before. At the Marshes', a fine for a dog run that had been approved in writing a decade earlier. At the Pruitts', a fine for a satellite dish. At the Harmons', a fine for a basketball hoop. At the Ellises', a fine for a garden wall. At the Boones', a fine for a camper that had been sold before Marty became president. Each household had a different letter, and each letter had Marty's phrasing and Brenda's signature at the bottom, and each household, when Kim asked if they had kept the paper, produced an envelope from a drawer or a folder or a kitchen counter, as if the whole street had been quietly keeping evidence without knowing it.
Helen, walking beside Kim, kept a list of her own in her notebook, and by the time we reached the end of the cul-de-sac the list matched Kim's list exactly: twelve households, twelve sets of letters, twelve stories that rhymed. I felt a strange mixture of anger and relief as we walked home in the gathering dark. Anger, because twelve families had been made to feel small in their own homes by letters that should never have been sent. Relief, because we were not alone in it anymore, and because the loneliness of those first fine letters, when Helen and I had sat at our kitchen table wondering if we were the only ones, was finally over. Kim thanked us at our door and said the audit would take time, because fraud files always took time, but that the foundation was now solid. The fines, the transfer, the duplicates, and the storage were no longer suspicions. They were lines in a ledger, with names and dates beside them, and a total that Olivia had already checked twice: two hundred and forty-seven thousand six hundred dollars.
The second tow attempt came at night, and it came quietly, which was the first thing that told me it was not a lawful job. A lawful tow, in my experience, arrives in daylight, with paperwork in hand and a driver who is willing to explain himself to anyone who asks. This one arrived after eleven o'clock, when the cul-de-sac was dark and most of the houses had their porch lights off and their curtains drawn. I was awake, because I had been awake a good deal in those weeks, lying in bed listening to the house settle and thinking about ledgers and signatures when I should have been asleep. Helen was asleep beside me, breathing evenly, and the house was quiet in the way a house is quiet when everyone in it trusts the night to leave them alone. Then the driveway camera chimed on my phone, a soft sound I had set myself, and I sat up and looked at the screen.