The Mustang He Reached For on Red Oak Lane

Chapter 26

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

My own share of that total was eleven thousand two hundred dollars. Olivia broke it down for me so I would understand it and so I could explain it to Helen without guessing. Seven thousand two hundred dollars in fines, the first two hundred plus the daily five hundred dollar fines that had run for fourteen days before Olivia's letter stopped the clock. Four thousand dollars in tow and storage charges billed on paper, the hook fee and the daily storage rate applied as if the Mustang had been sitting in Moran's lot, even though the tow on that Saturday morning had been stopped in my driveway and the car had never left my property. I had not paid that eleven thousand two hundred, and Olivia told me firmly not to pay a cent of it now, not while Kim's file was open and not while the question of whether any of it had ever been lawful was still being answered. Helen wrote the number in her notebook anyway, in her careful hand, and underlined it twice. She said she wanted to remember exactly what had been asked of us, so that when it was returned, as Olivia believed it would be, we would know the account was settled to the dollar.

Brenda's signature trail was the part of the audit that Helen found hardest to look at, not because it was complicated but because it was so plain. Kim laid the documents out in a row on the table in her office, and Helen and I leaned over them together, the way you lean over a map when you are trying to find where a road went wrong. There was Brenda's signature on the landscaping transfer, dated on a Tuesday in March, in the same blue ink she used for everything. There was her signature again on the cheque that moved the money onward, and again on the bank statement the following month, where the reserve balance had dropped and nobody had written a note explaining why. There was her signature on the gate invoices, both sets, the real one and the duplicate, signed on different days but in the same hurried hand, as if the second set had been slipped into a stack of ordinary bills and signed along with the rest. There was her signature on the pond invoices too, and on the monthly treasurer's reports that carried the same figures forward without comment, month after month, until the numbers began to look normal simply because they had been repeated so often.

Susan Keller, when Kim spoke to her, said she had noticed the pattern long before anyone else, because she was the secretary and it was her job to keep the minutes and to file the reports. Susan told Kim that she had asked Brenda about the landscaping transfer once, quietly, after a meeting, and Brenda had waved the question away and said Marty had approved it and that was enough. Susan had asked again, about the gate invoices, and Brenda had said the second invoice must have been for additional work, though Susan could not find any additional work in the minutes. Susan kept her own notes after that, in a notebook she did not show to anyone, and she kept copies of the minutes as they were actually taken, not as they were later typed up and circulated. Those duplicate minutes were the reason Kim's file had a spine to it, Olivia said, because they showed what had really been said in the room, and what had been changed afterward. I thought of Susan sitting in those meetings, quiet, taking notes, saying little, and I felt a surge of respect for her that I had not fully felt before. It takes a particular kind of courage to keep writing down the truth when the people around the table would prefer a different version of it.

Kim asked Helen and me to help her understand Brenda's routine, not to gossip about her but to establish how the money had moved. Helen knew Brenda's habits from years of neighbourhood life. Brenda did the HOA books at her kitchen table on Sunday evenings, Helen said, with the television on and a stack of papers beside her, and she prided herself on getting the cheques signed quickly so Marty could file them on Monday morning. Marty, Helen said, was the one who brought Brenda the stack. He was the one who explained, briefly, what each paper was for, and Brenda, trusting him as president and as a friend of long standing, signed where he pointed. I listened to Helen describe that routine and I felt something complicated settle in my chest, because it was easy to see how a person could slide from trust into carelessness and from carelessness into something worse, one Sunday evening at a time. Olivia warned us not to decide Brenda's intent for ourselves. That was Kim's job, and then the prosecutor's job, and our job was only to give them the paper and let the paper speak.

News in the same category

The Mustang He Reached For on Red Oak Lane

45 Part