Olivia went on, turning back to the folder. "Fourth," she said, "the board has to follow its own rules before it can fine you. It has to give proper notice of a meeting. It has to hold a vote in the open, or at least in a way the members can check. It has to adopt a rule before it enforces it, and it has to give you a real hearing, not a meeting where the president talks over you. From what I see here, on a first reading, I do not see proper notice for the vote Marty is quoting. I do not see minutes. I do not see a hearing notice that meets the covenants. That does not mean we have won anything yet. It means we have questions to ask, in writing, and we have a right to the records that would answer them."
She asked us about the video, and I told her Sophie had filmed it, and that George had saved a copy on a thumb drive, and that we had it saved in two places. She nodded and said that was good, and that we should not post it publicly yet, and that we should not edit it, and that we should keep the original file with its date and time intact. She asked about Deputy Ortiz, and I told her what he had said, and she wrote his name down and said she might want a copy of his report, if he had written one, because a deputy's note that there was no lawful tow order would matter later.
Then she talked about money, plainly, the way she talked about everything else. She said she worked on a capped fee for HOA cases, and she explained what the cap covered: the demand letter, the records request, the meeting preparation, and the first round of correspondence with the board. If the case went further, to a formal complaint or to court, she would tell us before the cap was reached, and we would decide together whether to go on. She did not promise a quick result. She said HOA cases were slow, and that Marty would likely send more letters before he sent fewer, and that we should expect that and not be rattled by it. She said the most important thing we could do in the next two weeks was to stay calm, stay organized, and let her put the board on notice, in writing, that we were represented and that all further communication should go through her.
That evening, Olivia's demand letter went out by email and by certified mail, or at least, her office told us it would go out the next morning, first thing. It asked the board for the full records: the meeting notices, the minutes, the vote record for the visible classic vehicle rule, the hearing notices, and the accounting for all fines assessed under that rule. It said we disputed the fines, and that we disputed the rule, and that all further contact should go through her office. Helen filed a copy of our intake notes in a new folder she labelled with Olivia's name, and she wrote the date on the tab, and she put it beside the Mustang folder on the shelf in our study, where she kept the important papers of our life together.
The next HOA meeting was scheduled for the following Thursday evening, in the community room at the small clubhouse near the pond at the edge of Cedar Hills Estates. The room was not large. It had folding chairs in rows, a long table at the front for the board, a microphone on a stand that Marty controlled, and a coffee urn in the corner that was usually empty by the time the meeting started. Helen and I arrived early, as we always did, and we took seats in the third row, where we could see the board table clearly and where Helen could take notes without blocking anyone's view. Paul came with us, because he wanted to be there, and because Helen and I both wanted a witness who was not us, someone who could remember what was said if Marty later said it differently.
My name was not spoken at first, but everyone in the room knew who he meant. Marty spoke for several minutes, in his smooth meeting voice, about the importance of consistent enforcement, about property values, about the board's duty to uphold the covenants, and about a vehicle that had been the subject of repeated notices. He did not mention the tow truck. He did not mention Deputy Ortiz. He did not mention Sophie's video. He spoke as if the whole matter were a simple case of a homeowner refusing to follow a clear rule, and he made it sound reasonable, if you did not know the details, and if you had not been standing in my driveway on Saturday morning.
When he finished, he looked in my direction and said, "Mr. Delaney, you have three minutes to address the board, if you wish."