Eighty-eight thousand dollars in fines was a lot of money for a neighbourhood of brick ranch homes and wide driveways, but Kim told us, in her careful way, that it was not the largest number in the file. The largest single item was a transfer of fifty-eight thousand dollars out of the landscaping reserve, a fund every household in Cedar Hills paid into each year so that the common areas, the entrance beds, the trees along the main road, and the grass around the pond would be kept up. The transfer had been approved, on paper, for a landscaping project that nobody in the neighbourhood could remember seeing done. There were no new beds at the entrance. There were no new trees along the main road. The grass around the pond looked exactly as it had looked the year before, a little worn at the edges where the ducks came up out of the water. Helen and I walked the entrance ourselves one evening, slowly, the way you walk a place you have lived in for years and suddenly see with fresh eyes. We looked for fresh mulch, for new plantings, for anything that fifty-eight thousand dollars might have bought. We found the same old beds, the same old shrubs, and a sprinkler head that had been broken since the spring.
Kim traced the transfer through the bank records, and that was where Brenda Sandoval's name began to appear again and again. Brenda was the treasurer, and her signature was on the transfer. It was also on the cheques that followed it, and on the monthly statements that should have raised a question and did not. Olivia explained to us, over coffee in her office, what that meant and what it did not mean. A signature on a cheque did not by itself prove that a person knew what the cheque was for, Olivia said, but a signature on a transfer, and then on the statements that hid the transfer, and then on the next month's accounts that carried the same shortfall forward, began to tell a story of its own. Kim put it more plainly. Brenda had signed without reading the backup, she said, or she had read it and signed anyway, and either way the paper trail led through her desk. Helen, who had known Brenda for years from school functions and neighbourhood gatherings, shook her head at that and said she had always thought Brenda was simply careless with details. Olivia said carelessness and complicity sometimes wore the same coat, and that it would be for the evidence, not for old acquaintance, to say which one Brenda had been wearing.
The gate and pond invoices came next, and they were the kind of fraud that only becomes clear when you lay two pieces of paper side by side and see that they are the same piece of work billed twice. Cedar Hills had a front gate that needed a new motor one winter, and a pond that needed dredging and new edging the following spring. Both jobs were real. Miguel Santos remembered the gate crew, because he had watched them work and had talked to the foreman about the wiring. I remembered the pond crew, because the trucks had blocked the main road for two mornings and Helen had complained, mildly, about the noise. The work had been done once, and done well enough, but the invoices had been paid twice, once to the real contractor and once to a second company with a similar name and a post office box for an address. The duplicate gate invoices added up to thirty-one thousand five hundred dollars. The duplicate pond invoices added up to twenty-seven thousand three hundred dollars. Together with the landscaping transfer and the fines, the numbers on Kim's whiteboard were climbing toward a total that made my stomach tighten every time I looked at it.
Then there was the storage. Moran Towing charged eighty-five dollars a day for storage, a rate Kim said was far above what other lots in the county charged, and far above what the HOA's own contract, if it had been fairly bid, would have allowed. The storage charges in the file did not belong only to us. Other households had cars, trailers, and work trucks towed, or threatened with towing, and the storage clock had started ticking on paper whether the vehicle had actually sat in Jake Moran's lot or not. Kim's team added those charges line by line, and they came to forty-two thousand eight hundred dollars. When Olivia added the four threads together on a sheet of her own notepaper, fines of eighty-eight thousand, the landscaping transfer of fifty-eight thousand, gate and pond duplicates of fifty-eight thousand eight hundred, and storage of forty-two thousand eight hundred, the total was two hundred and forty-seven thousand six hundred dollars across twelve households. She wrote the number twice, checked it twice, and then slid the paper across the table to me. I stared at it for a long moment, because a number that large did not feel like a neighbourhood dispute anymore. It felt like something else entirely, something that had been going on quietly, behind meeting minutes and polite letters, for a long time.