The first small thing was the trash cart. It was gone from beside the garage one morning, just gone, as if it had never been there. I noticed it when I went out to take the recycling to the curb, and I stood in the driveway for a moment looking at the empty space where the cart should have been, trying to remember whether I had moved it myself the night before and forgotten. I had not. Dana had not. Grace had not. Owen had not. It was simply not there. We found it later that day, behind a retention pond at the far end of the subdivision, tipped on its side in the tall grass, and I dragged it home feeling irritated and vaguely foolish, because who steals a trash cart, and why would anyone bother? I assumed teenagers. That was my explanation, and it felt reasonable at the time. Teenagers do stupid things. They move things. They tip things over. They leave them in strange places and laugh about it later. A trash cart behind a retention pond fit that story well enough that I did not look for another one. I remember the walk back with the cart, the wheels catching in the grass, the lid flapping open and shut, and the way I kept glancing at the houses I passed, wondering idly whether anyone had seen anything, and then dismissing the thought, because a missing trash cart was not the kind of thing you asked neighbors about. It was the kind of thing you handled yourself, with a shrug, and moved on from, and that is what I did. I put the cart back beside the garage, I latched the lid, and I went inside and did not think about it again until the next thing happened, which is exactly how small things work when they are still small. They do not demand attention. They just accumulate, quietly, one after another, while you are busy explaining each one away.
Three days later, two sprinkler heads were broken along the side yard. I found them in the morning when I walked the property line, the way I sometimes did in the spring, checking for winter damage and seeing what needed attention before the lawn really started growing. The heads were snapped clean off, not worn down or cracked from cold, but broken, lying in the grass beside the small holes where they had been. I stood there looking at them and tried to think of a reason. The landscaper, probably. That was the explanation I settled on. Maybe someone on a crew had caught them with a mower or a trimmer and not said anything. Maybe it was an accident that nobody wanted to own up to. It was annoying, and it would cost a little money to fix, but it was the kind of thing that happens to a yard in the spring, and I filed it away under maintenance rather than suspicion.
Then someone pulled several solar lights from Dana's garden and left them lying in the grass. Dana had placed those lights herself, along the edge of her flower beds, and she took pride in them, in the way they made the garden look in the evening when they came on one by one, small warm points of light tracing the shape of the beds she had tended since we moved in. She knew exactly where each one stood, because she had chosen the spacing herself, stepping back to check the line from the porch, adjusting a stake here and there until the row looked right to her. One afternoon she went out to the garden and found them pulled out of the soil and scattered across the lawn, some on their sides, some upside down, their little stakes pointing at the sky, the careful line she had made broken apart as if someone had run a hand through it without caring where the pieces landed. Wind? Maybe. That was what I said when she showed me, and she frowned at me, because even then the explanation did not quite fit. Wind does not pull lights neatly out of the ground and lay them in the grass. Wind knocks things over. Wind scatters. It does not uproot a row of lights and arrange them like that. But I said wind anyway, because I did not have a better explanation, and because the alternative, that someone had come into our yard and pulled up Dana's garden lights on purpose, felt too strange and too hostile to say out loud about a neighbor we had lived beside for seven years.
The mailbox was bent backward one morning. I found it when I went out to get the paper, and I stopped on the walk and stared at it, because a mailbox does not bend backward on its own. The post was tilted, the box itself was dented and pushed back at an angle, as if something had hit it from the front with enough force to shove it out of shape. Probably a car, I told myself. Someone backing out of a driveway too fast, or a delivery driver misjudging a turn, or a teenager clipping it late at night and driving off without stopping. That happened on streets like ours. Mailboxes got hit. It was one of the small, stupid costs of living on a suburban street, and I straightened it as best I could and told Dana it was probably a car, and she nodded, and we moved on.