I called the prosecutor's victim-witness coordinator that week and explained what we were finding. I told her about the clips, and about Foster's reports, and about the timing, and I tried to be as factual as I could, because I did not want to sound like a man who had worked himself into a theory. She listened, and she gave us advice that was standard, and that I have since come to appreciate for its steadiness: do not confront Dylan, do not contact witnesses ourselves, keep evidence, report threats. Standard advice. It sounded almost boring, after everything we had been through, but boring was what we needed. We needed to stop improvising. We needed to stop trying to solve this ourselves, with cameras and folders and late-night conversations at the kitchen table. We needed a process, and we needed to stay inside it.
That was also the week we decided to hire an attorney of our own. Not because Grace had done anything wrong. She had not. She had told the truth about what she saw, and she had stayed with an injured man until help arrived, and she had answered every question put to her honestly. We hired an attorney because the situation had become too complicated for me to trust my instincts alone. I had trusted my instincts when I explained away the small incidents, and my instincts had been wrong. I had trusted my instincts when I assumed the shed was the whole story, and the cameras had shown me it was not. I needed someone who could look at the videos and the reports and the threat and the note and tell us what they meant, legally, and what we should do next. Her name was Karen Liu, and I will come to her properly later in this story, because she deserves a proper introduction. For now, it is enough to say that hiring her was the moment we stopped treating this as a neighbor problem and started treating it as something that required professional help.
But before Karen, before the investigator, before the recordings that would later change everything, there was Foster's visit, and there was the kitchen table, and there was the folder of clips, and there was the list of dates I had written out by hand. March 31 and April 1. April 12 and April 14. April 22 and April 25. I looked at that list for a long time after Dana had gone to bed, and I thought about Gwen standing in our yard with her phone, photographing things she had moved or damaged, and I thought about the reports Foster had described, and I thought about Grace standing behind us the night before, saying, "Maybe she's trying to make us look crazy."
That had sounded strange until the next day. After Foster's visit, it did not sound strange anymore. It sounded like the beginning of an explanation, one that we did not yet fully understand, but that fit the facts better than any explanation Dana or I had offered. A neighbor who files false reports, and who photographs incidents she creates herself, and who times those incidents to the progress of a legal case, is not simply angry. She is building something. And what she was building, we would soon learn, was a story about our family, a story in which we were not witnesses, but enemies, and in which Grace's testimony could be dismissed as the product of a feud rather than the truth of what she saw on a service road one Thursday afternoon in March.
I did not know that yet, sitting at the kitchen table with my list of dates. I only knew that the pattern was real, that the documentation was real, and that we had video, and that Foster had told us to save everything, and that we would. That was enough for that night. It had to be enough, because the next day would bring a new piece of the puzzle, and the day after that another, and the story would keep unfolding in the way it had been unfolding all along: not in a single dramatic revelation, but in small, dated, documented steps, each one too minor to matter on its own, each one photographed, each one filed, each one timed to something happening in a case that Gwen could not control, and that she was trying, desperately, to control from our side yard, one moved light and one bent mailbox and one tipped bin at a time.