Grace, standing behind us, said, "Her attorney."
I turned around. "What?"
"Maybe she's trying to make us look crazy," Grace said.
I remember the shape of that sentence because it sounded so strange coming from a seventeen-year-old, and because I dismissed it almost immediately, and because it turned out to be closer to the truth than anything Dana or I said that night. At the time, it sounded like something Grace had picked up from a television show, or something she was saying because she was frightened and trying to make sense of a situation that did not make sense. A neighbor photographing moved solar lights did not obviously connect to an attorney. A neighbor trying to make us look crazy did not obviously connect to anything we could prove. But Grace said it, and the words stayed in the room after she said them, and Dana and I looked at each other, and neither of us had a better explanation.
The next clip I found was dated April 10. Gwen came near the mailbox. I need to be careful about this one, because the camera did not show exactly what she touched. The angle was not perfect. The mailbox sits at the edge of the frame, and Gwen's body blocked part of it, and her hands were not clearly visible in the clip. What the camera showed was Gwen standing near the mailbox for a short time in the morning, and then walking away. What we knew from the rest of that morning was that the mailbox was bent later that morning. I found it bent when I went out to get the mail, the post leaning back at an angle that had not been there the day before, the metal box itself dented and twisted in a way that did not look like wind or a passing car. And then, at 8:30 that same morning, Gwen came back, and the camera caught her clearly this time, standing at the end of the driveway with her phone raised, photographing the mailbox.
I watched that clip three times. The first time, I was looking for what she had done to the mailbox, and the camera would not show me. The second time, I was looking at the photograph she was taking, at the careful way she framed it, the way she held the phone steady. The third time, I was looking at her face, or what I could see of it from that distance, and I could not read anything from it. She did not look triumphant. She did not look guilty. She looked like a person taking a photograph of a damaged mailbox, which is exactly what she was doing. The problem was that the damage had appeared on the same morning she had been standing beside it, and she was the one documenting it, and nobody else had been near it.
The April 14 clip came next, and it carried its own kind of weight, because April 14 was a day I could place without checking a calendar. The family had been at Grace's track meet that afternoon. I remembered the meet because Grace had run well, and because we had stayed until the end, and because we had come home tired and sunburned in the way you get sunburned sitting on metal bleachers in April. While we were gone, Gwen walked beside the property line. The camera caught her there, moving along the edge of our yard, unhurried, the way a person walks when they are not worried about being seen. One of the trash bins was later found tipped near the street, its lid off, some of its contents spilled onto the grass near the curb. And again, there was a photograph. Gwen raised her phone and took a picture of the bin where it lay.
By then, Dana had stopped asking what Gwen was taking pictures for. She was watching the clips the way I was watching them, and the pattern was starting to form in front of us, the way a pattern forms when you lay photographs out on a table and step back. It was not only that things were being moved or damaged. It was that every moved or damaged thing was being recorded, by the same person, with the same phone, in the same careful way. The solar lights. The mailbox. The trash bin. Each incident on its own could be explained, or at least argued about. Together, they looked like something else. They looked like a collection.