That was certainly part of it. I know that now, and I knew it then, and it was not wrong as far as it went. But it was not all of it. It was not even the most important part of it, though I would not understand that for weeks, and I would not have the proof for it until much later, when the cameras and the recordings and the reports began to line up into a pattern I could finally see whole. In that first afternoon, sitting on the patio steps with the police on their way and the damage all around me, I thought the warning was the whole story. I thought "This is only the beginning" meant more broken things, more frightening days, more pressure, until we gave in.
I was wrong about what the beginning meant. But I was not wrong about the warning landing. It landed. It landed the way a threat lands when the person making it has already shown you that they are willing to do what they say. Gwen had not lost control in our backyard that afternoon. She had shown control, and she had told me, in six words, that she intended to keep showing it. That was the part I carried into the house with me when the police arrived, and that was the part I could not shake off that night, no matter how many times I told myself that a shed could be repaired and a window could be replaced and a bicycle could be fixed. The warning was not about the shed. The shed was only the first sentence.
I am Scott Merritt. I was forty-six years old when Gwen Pritchard stood in my backyard beside the broken shed and told me this was only the beginning. My wife, Dana, teaches fourth grade. My daughter, Grace, was seventeen. My son, Owen, was twelve. We lived, and still live, in a quiet subdivision outside Overland Park, Kansas, the kind of place that looks nothing like the setting for a legal fight.
I say that because it is true, and because it is part of why everything that happened felt so strange for so long. Our street had basketball hoops in driveways and trimmed lawns and two-car garages. In the evenings, after dinner, children rode scooters up and down the sidewalk while their parents stood in front yards talking about school and weather and whose turn it was to bring snacks to the next game. It was not a perfect street. No street is. But it was an ordinary street, and ordinary streets are supposed to be the places where nothing much happens, where the worst thing that occurs in a given month is a fence that needs painting or a tree that drops too many leaves into a neighbor's yard.
Gwen Pritchard and her husband moved into the blue two-story house next door seven years earlier, with their son, Dylan. Seven years is a long time to live next door to someone. It is long enough to learn their routines, to recognize their cars, to know when they are home and when they are away, to wave when you pass each other in the driveway and to stop and chat for a minute about the rain or the roadwork or the new restaurant that opened near the highway. It is also, in our case, long enough to know that we were neighbors without being friends.
I want to be precise about that, because it matters later, when other people try to describe what our two families were to each other. We were not enemies. We were not close. We were the kind of neighbors who borrowed extension cords and returned packages that had been delivered to the wrong address and complained, in the friendly, exasperated way neighbors complain, about rabbits eating the gardens. Dana would bring over a plate of cookies at Christmas, and Gwen would bring over a plate of something at Thanksgiving, and we would stand in each other's doorways for a few minutes and talk about the kids and the weather and then go back to our own houses. That was the whole relationship, and for seven years it was enough. Nothing in it explained why Gwen would one day be standing in the middle of our damaged property, calmly admitting that she had done it.