That evening, I sat with Dana and Grace at the table and told them about the list. I read the dates out loud, one by one, and I watched Grace's face as she heard them. She did not argue. She did not cry. She went very still, the way a person goes still when they realize someone has been telling a story about them that they never got to hear until it was already written down somewhere official. Dana asked me to read the March 18 item again, the one about hostility from Grace, and I did, and Dana shook her head and said she could not think of a single day in March when Grace had even been near Dylan outside of school, let alone hostile toward him. Grace said nothing for a while, and then she said, in a voice that sounded smaller than usual, that it felt strange to have to prove she had not been fighting with people she barely talked to. I told her she did not have to prove anything to us, and that Karen would handle the rest, and that our job was the same job the coordinator had given us: keep everything, write everything down, and do not go looking for a confrontation.
Owen came into the kitchen then, looking for a snack, and the conversation stopped the way conversations stop when a younger child walks in, not because we were hiding something from him exactly, but because he was twelve and his bicycle had already been under a shelf in a broken shed, and that was enough for him to carry. He asked whether Gwen was going to come back, and I told him the truth as far as I knew it, which was that I did not know, but that we had cameras and police reports and a lawyer now, and that if anything else happened we would know about it and deal with it properly. He seemed to accept that. He took his snack and went back to his room. Dana and I looked at each other, and I knew we were both thinking the same thing: that a twelve-year-old should not have to ask that question about the woman next door, and that a seventeen-year-old should not have to sit at a kitchen table listening to a list of invented fights.
The next morning, Karen called again, and this time she asked me to come in and look at something with her. She had gone back through our footage more carefully than I had, and she had found a clip I had not looked at closely enough. It was from the driveway camera, on the day Gwen damaged the shed, and the timestamp on it stopped me cold when I saw it.
It was 2:41 p.m.
Fifteen minutes before I arrived home.
I had come home carrying a grocery bag, and I had found Gwen standing in the backyard beside the shed, and I had assumed, in the shock of that moment, that she had simply been there when I walked in, waiting, the way a person waits when they want to be seen. What the clip showed was something more deliberate than that. At 2:41 p.m., Gwen was standing near the side gate, on the phone. The audio was faint, and I had to listen to it, turning the volume up and leaning in, but the words were clearer than I expected, and once I heard them, I could not unhear them.
"He'll be back soon."
There was a pause. A woman's voice answered, but the words on the other end could not be made out, and I do not pretend otherwise. I have never known who she was talking to in that call, and I have never tried to guess in a way that would turn a guess into a fact. What I know is what Gwen said next, and what she said next changed everything I thought I understood about that afternoon.
"No, I want him to see it."
Another pause. Another unheard reply.
"If he comes over, I'll record him."
And then, after one more pause, the sentence that tied the whole pattern together in a way no list of dates ever could:
"I need them to show what they're really like."