Then she asked a question I had not expected, and the way she asked it told me she already knew it was the kind of question that changes a case.
"Has anyone from Dylan's defense contacted you claiming your family has a preexisting dispute with the Pritchards?"
"No," I said.
Karen nodded, but she did not look relieved. She looked like a person waiting for the second half of an answer.
"Not yet," she said.
I remember the way that landed. Not yet. She was not predicting bad luck. She was telling me that the shape of what Gwen had been doing pointed somewhere specific, and that somewhere was a claim we had not heard yet but should be ready for. I asked her what she meant, and she said only that we should keep everything exactly as it was, and that if anyone from Dylan's side contacted us, we were to send them to her first, before we answered anything. Dana wrote that down too. We were becoming a family that wrote things down.
Two days later, the contact came, and it came the way Karen had said it should: through her first, not through us. Dylan's defense investigator was named Robert Shaw. I never spoke to him directly in that first conversation, and I am glad of that, because I was in no state to be polite about anything connected to Gwen, and politeness turned out to matter. Karen called me after she spoke to him, and she told me what he had said in a voice that stayed even all the way through, which I took as its own kind of warning. Shaw was professional. He was polite. He was not, Karen said, the villain of anything. He had called her because Dylan's legal team had been informed of something they thought she should know, and he wanted to put it to her properly rather than let it arrive as a surprise later.
What they had been informed of was a "longstanding neighbor conflict" between our family and the Pritchards, a conflict that might affect Grace's reliability as a witness.
Karen asked him the obvious question. "Longstanding since when?"
Shaw had a list. Karen read it back to me slowly, and I wrote each item down, because I wanted to be sure I was hearing the dates right and not inventing a worse version of them in my head afterward.
February 3: a dispute concerning trash near the boundary.
February 19: a conflict involving outdoor lights.
March 7: an alleged argument involving me.
March 18: reported hostility from Grace.
I sat with that list for a long time after Karen finished reading it. The accident had happened on March 21. If those dates were accurate, then the story they told was simple and ugly: our family and the Pritchards had been feuding for weeks before Grace ever saw Dylan's truck on that service road, and her statement to the police could be described, by someone who wanted to describe it that way, as retaliation. A hostile neighboring family, settling a score, using a crash as an excuse. That was the shape Karen had been waiting for when she said "not yet."
But we had never had those conflicts. I want to say that plainly, because everything else in this chapter depends on it. There had been no February argument about trash near the boundary that I was part of. There had been no February fight about outdoor lights. There had been no March argument involving me that matched what Shaw described. And Grace had not been hostile toward anyone on March 18, or on any date I could name, because Grace had barely spoken to Dylan since the accident, and before the accident their lives had overlapped only in the thin way that neighbors' children's lives overlap at school.
So where had the list come from? The answer, when Karen laid it out, was surprisingly simple, and that simplicity made it worse, because it meant the whole thing had been built out of material that had been sitting in plain sight for months.