I did not call the prosecutor's office because I had a plan. I called because I had run out of explanations that made me feel better, and I was tired of standing in my own yard trying to decide whether the next strange thing was a coincidence or a message. The morning after we sat with the footage and watched Gwen move Dana's lights and photograph them, I sat at the kitchen table with the police report number for the shed, the photographs from my phone, and a list I had started on the back of an envelope. The list was not long, but it was the kind of list that changes how you read everything that came before it. Trash cart. Sprinkler heads. Solar lights. Mailbox. Basketball. Gate. Furniture cover. Note. Shed. I kept turning the envelope over in my hands, as if the other side might have an answer written on it. It did not.
Dana was at school. Grace was at school. Owen was at school. The house was quiet in a way that made the quiet feel like part of the problem, because for weeks the trouble had arrived while we were out living ordinary lives, and I had come home each time and explained it away. I called the number Officer Foster had given us, and I asked for the prosecutor's victim-witness coordinator. I knew only that Grace was a witness, that someone was now standing in our yard breaking things, and that I needed somebody whose job it was to tell a family what not to do next.
The coordinator listened without interrupting. I told her about the shed, about Gwen standing there, about the sentence she had said to me, about the note under Grace's windshield wiper, and about the footage we had found. I told her about the reports Foster had mentioned, the ones we had never heard about until Foster named them. I did not dress any of it up. I gave her dates where I had them and told her plainly where I was guessing. When I finished, there was a short pause, and then she gave me advice that sounded too simple for the size of the mess we were in.
She told us not to confront Dylan. She told us not to contact witnesses ourselves. She told us to keep the evidence, all of it, in its original form where we could, and to make copies. She told us to report any further threats right away, and to write down dates and times while they were fresh, because memory softens edges that matter later. None of it was dramatic. It was practical, and it was the first thing in days that made me feel as though somebody else had a clear view of the shape of this thing. I wrote it down on the same envelope, underneath my list, because I did not trust myself to remember the exact wording later. Do not confront. Do not contact. Keep everything. Report threats. Write it down.
That night, Dana and I sat at the table after the kids were in bed, and we talked about hiring a lawyer. We did not hire a lawyer because Grace had done anything wrong. She had not. She had told the police what she saw, and she had stayed with a hurt man until help arrived, and nothing about that needed defending. We hired a lawyer because the situation had grown too complicated for me to trust my instincts, and my instincts had already failed us once. My instincts had told me the trash cart was teenagers and the sprinkler heads were the landscaper and the lights were the wind. My instincts had told me spring was an explanation. I did not want to navigate the next part of this on instinct alone.
Her name was Karen Liu. A friend of a friend gave us the name, and when we met her, she did not waste time telling us how she felt about Gwen or about Dylan or about any of it. She asked for the material. She wanted the videos, the police reports, Gwen's threat, the anonymous note, the photographs I had taken in the yard, and the dates Foster had given us. She spread it out the way a person spreads out a map when she is trying to figure out where a road actually goes, not where you assumed it went. She watched the clips more than once. She read the note again. She asked me to walk her through the shed afternoon a second time, and then a third, stopping me at small points I had not thought were points at all. What time had I come home. Where exactly had Gwen been standing. What had she been wearing. Where had her hands been. Whether she had looked at the camera.