The Woman From Next Door Deliberately Damaged My Family's Property — Then She Looked at Me and Said This Is Only the Beginning

Chapter 27

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Officer Megan Foster handled our property-damage report after the shed incident. I had spoken to officers before, on the night of the accident and when we handed over the note, but Foster was the first officer who sat with us long enough to make me feel that the whole picture was being taken seriously. She came to the house, walked through the backyard with me, looked at the shed door and the window and the shelves and the bench, and took notes in a small notebook that she held in one hand while she photographed the damage with the other. She asked me to walk her through the exchange with Gwen, and I did, slowly, including the part where Gwen said yes, she had done it, and the part where she said, "This is only the beginning, Scott." Foster wrote that down without reacting, which I appreciated. She did not tell me it was just a neighbor dispute. She did not tell me to work it out between ourselves. She took the shed incident seriously because Gwen had essentially admitted what she did, and because the photographs I had taken, and the cameras we had installed, supported it.

It was during that visit, after we had finished walking the yard and had come back inside to sit at the kitchen table, that Foster told us something I had never heard before. She set her notebook down, looked at me, and said, "Mr. Merritt, Ms. Pritchard has made reports involving your household."

I stared at her. "What reports?"

"I can't summarize everything from memory," Foster said. She was careful with her words, the way officers are careful when they are telling you something that exists in a system you cannot see. "How many?" I asked. She paused, and then she said, "Several contacts."

Several contacts. I had never heard about any of them. Not one. Dana had never heard about them either. We sat at our own kitchen table and learned that our neighbor had been filing reports about our household, and that those reports existed somewhere in a system, with dates and times and numbers attached to them, and that we had been living our ordinary lives, going to school and work and track meets, while a file about us was quietly growing.

Foster went back to her records and checked. She came back with the complaints, and she laid them out for us one by one, and each one was more bewildering than the last, because each one described something that had not happened, or had not happened the way it was described, and each one involved a member of my family doing something I knew they had not done.

One complaint alleged that I had walked onto Gwen's property during an argument. That was false. I had not walked onto Gwen's property during an argument, because there had been no argument on our side of the fence that involved me entering her yard. I had stood in my own yard. I had stood on the sidewalk. I had spoken to Gwen from my own property. I had not crossed onto hers to argue with her. The complaint described a scene that did not exist.

Another complaint claimed that Dana had repeatedly thrown yard waste near Gwen's fence. That was also false. Dana is a fourth-grade teacher who spends her Saturdays grading papers and working in her garden, and she does not throw yard waste at anyone's fence, repeatedly or otherwise. She bags leaves. She composts what she can. She keeps her side of the property line tidy, because that is the kind of person she is, and because she has never had any interest in a fence-line war with a neighbor. The idea that she had been repeatedly throwing yard waste near Gwen's fence was so far from anything Dana would do that I almost laughed when Foster read it, and then I stopped laughing, because it was written down somewhere as a complaint, and written-down things have a way of outliving the laughter.

A third complaint described Grace as "aggressively confronting" Dylan near the street. That one hit harder than the others, because it involved my daughter, and because it was so completely untrue in a way I could prove to myself without any records at all. Grace had not spoken to Dylan since the accident. Not once. Not in the hallway at school, not on the street, not anywhere. She had seen him, of course, in the way you see people you know in a small community, but she had not spoken to him, and she certainly had not aggressively confronted him near the street. The complaint invented a confrontation that had never taken place, and it put Grace's name on it, and it described her in language that made a seventeen-year-old witness sound like an aggressor.

News in the same category

The Woman From Next Door Deliberately Damaged My Family's Property — Then She Looked at Me and Said This Is Only the Beginning

45 Part