A fourth report claimed that I had damaged one of Gwen's security lights. I had not. I had never touched one of Gwen's security lights. I had never been near them with any tool, or any intention, or any reason. I barely knew where they were mounted, beyond a general awareness that her house had lights along the side facing our yard. The report said otherwise, and the report existed, and that was the point.
Nothing had resulted in charges. Foster was clear about that, and I believed her, because if charges had resulted, we would have heard about them. Most of the complaints were documented as neighborhood complaints, which is a category that sounds minor, and in a sense it is minor, because it does not mean anyone was arrested or charged or taken to court. But that was exactly the point, and Foster understood it even before I did, I think. The complaints did not need to result in charges to matter. They needed to exist. They needed a date, and a time, and a report number, and a description of a conflict. Once they existed, they could be pointed to. They could be listed. They could be read aloud by someone who wanted to suggest that there had been trouble between our families for a long time. The existence of the complaints was the product. The charges were never the goal.
Foster said, "There's another thing."
"What?" I asked.
"Ms. Pritchard submitted photographs with two complaints."
That stopped me cold, because I had spent the previous night watching clips of Gwen photographing things in our yard, and now Foster was telling me that photographs had been submitted with complaints about our household, and the two facts fit together in a way that made my stomach tighten. "What photographs?" I asked.
"One showed objects near her boundary," Foster said. "Another showed what she described as damage after a confrontation."
I thought about the solar lights, moved and photographed. I thought about the mailbox, photographed at 8:30 in the morning. I thought about the trash bin, tipped near the street and photographed while we were at a track meet. I thought about the gate, open and photographed. I did not know, in that moment, whether the photographs Foster was describing were the same photographs Gwen had taken in our yard, or different ones, or photographs of things Gwen had arranged near her own boundary. Foster did not show me the photographs that day, and she did not need to, for me to understand the shape of what she was telling me. Gwen had been creating a record, and then she had been submitting pieces of that record as part of complaints, and the complaints had been filed, and the file had grown.
Dana, who had been listening quietly beside me, said, "She created some of that."
Foster looked at us. "You have video?" she asked.
"Yes," I said.
"Save everything," Foster said.
We did. We had already started saving everything the night before, when I copied the clips to a folder and labeled them by date. Now Foster's advice gave that habit a formal weight it had not had before. Save everything. Not because we expected a trial the next week, but because we had learned, in the space of two days, that our neighbor had been building a paper trail about us while we were not looking, and that the only defense against a paper trail is a better, truer paper trail of your own. The cameras, the photographs I had taken of the shed, the note, the clips, the dates: all of it went into folders, and the folders went onto a backup drive, and the backup drive went into a drawer in my office where I knew I could find it.