Damian had been standing by the fireplace long enough for the guests to stop trying to bring him into their conversations. The house belonged to people he had known years ago. He had come because he had promised to see them, and now he was looking at a silver frame on the mantel and wondering how soon he could leave without offending anyone. The polished corner of the frame caught the afternoon light each time someone crossed in front of the window.
He noticed the rabbit first. Its ears hung over the arms of a small girl in a lilac dress. She stopped a little way from him, looked up and waited. Damian crouched so she would not have to tip her head back. He thought she was going to ask him to get something from one of the high shelves. Instead she asked if she could kiss him. When he asked her why, she said he looked sad. The plainness of the answer made him want to look away, but the child was still waiting for an answer. He told her it was all right.
She leaned in for a tiny kiss and straightened again, with the rabbit still held against her dress. No one said anything. Her attention went past his shoulder to the mantel. She raised one arm and asked who the little girl was. The question made him turn his head. The nearest silver frame held a man in evening clothes. There were other photographs near it, set back into the corner. Damian knew the one she meant from the direction of her finger, although from where he knelt he could see only the gleam of its edge.
He looked at the child again. That girl had been his daughter, he said. She had died ten years ago. It took him a moment to get the second sentence out. The child put her hand back on the rabbit’s head and told him her mommy had that picture. Damian waited for her to add that it looked like one she knew, or that she had seen it at someone else’s house. She did neither. He leaned a little closer and asked her to repeat herself. She said her mommy told her that girl did not die.
For a moment Damian could hear a spoon touching a saucer clear across the room. He did not want to ask the child a question that might frighten her, so he asked about the rabbit. She told him it was named Peter and that one of its ears had been repaired. He said it was a good name. The child’s mother was by the window. Damian asked if she could come over and look at the mantel with them. Her name was Ruth. He had seen her earlier without knowing who she was.
Ruth brought her phone over because she thought the child wanted to show everyone a photograph of the rabbit. Then she saw the picture Damian indicated. She took her time before answering. It had belonged to her older sister, she said. There was a copy in an envelope at home, and her daughter had asked her about it months ago. Ruth remembered the question because it came on an afternoon when she was trying to find a set of spare keys and had opened a drawer she otherwise kept closed.
Damian asked what she had told the child. Ruth said she had been explaining what her sister believed, and she had used words simple enough for a five-year-old. She had said the girl in the photograph might have survived. Her sister had been a volunteer at a roadside shelter during the year of the floods and had remembered a child being brought in with a coat wrapped around her. She had written the date and the name of the hospital on the back of a photograph when she was trying to match a notice she had seen.
Damian wanted to tell Ruth the date was wrong before she finished. He had spent ten years learning when people were about to give him an answer worse than silence. He could feel himself preparing for one. Ruth saw him watching her and offered the phone so he could look at a photograph of the back of the envelope. He read the date twice. The hospital was a town away from the one he had been told to look in. That was a fact he could check. There were a hundred things he wanted it to mean, and he could check it anyway.
Ruth asked if he wanted her to bring the envelope tomorrow. He said he would meet her wherever it was easiest. They agreed on a café near the library, where Ruth’s daughter liked to look at picture books. Then Damian asked the girl if he could see the repaired ear. She held Peter up. The stitches were neat and very small, in thread a shade lighter than the rest of the rabbit. He told her whoever had fixed it had done good work. She explained that her mother had fixed it while she was asleep.