When Ella saw Damian looking sad, she stopped beside him with her stuffed rabbit and offered him a kiss. Then she pointed toward the pictures on the mantel, and he told her he had lost his daughter ten years ago

Chapter 10

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

They checked the contact sheets. One roll had been developed in a different town a week after the others. Its envelope carried a pencilled name that Ruth did not recognise. Celia remembered lending her camera to a volunteer on a morning when she was transporting blankets. That volunteer might have taken the picture. She was alive, according to a recent Christmas card, but had moved north. Ruth suggested telephoning her. Celia said they should not call until they had asked whether the intermediary thought the contact might be useful. She had begun to appreciate the distinction between wanting another witness and having permission to involve someone in an investigation about a living person.

They made a list of the photographs whose dates were reliable, then a separate list of those dated only by memory. Ruth scanned the images without altering them and saved the files under the envelope numbers. The work took hours. Her daughter returned before they finished and wanted to know why the table was full of old people. Ruth smiled and said the photographs were from a time before she was born. The child asked whether Peter the rabbit had been alive then. Ruth said Peter was a toy and had a complicated history of his own. Satisfied, the girl went to find him.

After supper Celia told Ruth about an event she had not spoken of since the flood. A woman had come to the shelter asking about her son. She had arrived with a written description and a small pair of shoes. Celia had taken the description to the desk, asked the volunteers and checked the admission list. No one could find the boy. The woman returned two days later and thanked her for looking. Celia never learned what happened. She still remembered the shoes, which had green laces, and the woman's quiet manner. The memory had become attached to every list she prepared afterward. If a name was absent, she made herself check again. Even so, she had missed things. A shelter was not a place where everything could be made orderly by care.

Ruth asked whether Celia blamed herself for the errors that followed. Celia said she was wary of the question. Responsibility was not distributed by how much guilt a person could bear. She had made mistakes; she could identify some of them and change how she worked afterward. She could not take responsibility for every event simply because she had been present. She also did not want to be absolved so quickly that nobody examined the records she had helped create. Ruth sat with this answer. Her sister had always been more capable of tolerating an unfinished sentence than Ruth herself.

When they packed the photographs away, Celia kept one picture out: the empty low table with the clock above it. She wrote a note on the back of a new sheet, identifying exactly what she remembered and what she did not. The original photograph remained unmarked. The small act made her feel steadier. She telephoned Damian the next day to tell him that another set of pictures existed, though none identified the child. He thanked her without sounding disappointed. Celia was grateful that he had learned, at least for that conversation, to accept information in the shape it had.

“Gavin, I think. Or Graham. I wrote quickly. I've tried to find him. I didn't get far.”

She explained how she had sent a letter to the temporary inquiry desk with photographs and details, and how the reply simply acknowledged receipt. After the relief offices closed, the case numbers changed. Eventually she was told the matter had already been resolved. She had been twenty-four, living on shifts and temporary work. She had accepted the official answer while distrusting it.

“Did you tell the family?” Damian asked.

Celia received a letter from an old volunteer she had contacted through the intermediary. The volunteer, June Palmer, now lived near the coast and remembered one night at the shelter when a child had become frightened by the noise of rain against the windows. She had sat beside the child and drawn animals on the back of a food inventory. The drawings did not survive. She remembered that the child had asked whether bridges could be repaired. She did not remember the child's name and had no reason to believe the memory uniquely identified Iris.

The letter included a description of the room. There had been a green door at the far end and a row of folding tables beneath fluorescent lights. The volunteers had been instructed to keep the central aisle clear for stretchers and wheelchairs. Celia read the account twice and then visited the old building, now used for community classes. The door was still green, though the paint had faded. She asked the caretaker whether she could look at the hall and explained why. He let her in and waited by the entrance, reminding her that a class would begin in half an hour.

The room was smaller than she remembered. The windows were low. Someone had hung children's artwork on a noticeboard, and a stack of chairs occupied the corner where the emergency supplies had once been stored. Celia stood beneath the clock and tried to picture the crowded hall. She could hear again the scrape of benches, the calling of names and the persistent rain. She was aware how easily the room prompted memory. It would have been tempting to say she suddenly recognised exactly where the child had sat. Instead she made a sketch of the current layout and noted the differences between what she saw and what she recalled.

News in the same category

When Ella saw Damian looking sad, she stopped beside him with her stuffed rabbit and offered him a kiss. Then she pointed toward the pictures on the mantel, and he told her he had lost his daughter ten years ago

45 Part