Martin served potatoes and left the pan on a board between them. He remembered the morning of the flood differently. He had been on the road, trying to reach his sister's house, when a policeman directed him back. For years he had believed he ought to have found another route. He told Damian about stopping at a petrol station and buying a packet of mints he did not want, simply because the shop was open and the ordinary act of paying for something made the day briefly manageable. He still remembered the brand. He had forgotten the face of the cashier.
'You never told me that,' Damian said.
'You had enough to remember.'
'I wasn't the only one who lost her.'
Martin looked down at the pan. Neither of them had phrased it that way before. Their grief had never been equal, and Damian did not pretend it was, but he could now see the years in which everyone had spoken around him as though he might break if their own memories touched his.
After lunch they opened the spare room. The shelves held envelopes, old magazines and a suitcase with a broken wheel. At the bottom of one box was the yellow raincoat Iris had worn in the photograph. Its lining was torn at the pocket. Damian had once planned to repair it, then decided that altering anything she owned would be a kind of erasure. He spread the coat across the bed and found a small paper ticket sewn into the lining by the manufacturer. There was nothing hidden there. Nothing to decode. The simple absence of a clue disappointed him enough to make him laugh, and the laugh startled Martin.
'That is a child's coat,' Martin said gently. 'It doesn't have to be part of an investigation.'
Damian sat on the bed. 'I know. But I'm having trouble remembering that.'
They folded the coat together. In another box they found the drawing of a ship Iris had made during a visit to the seaside, its deck crowded with stick figures and one enormous bird in the sky. Damian set it on the bed beside a few school reports and a birthday card. The reports described a child who was good at reading, inclined to interrupt and sometimes careless with numbers. They had become relics only because there would be no more of them. He wanted to tell whoever she might have become that her teacher once called her impatient. He also understood that, if the person they sought really was Iris, she might have no interest in being told who she had been at seven.
Before Martin left, he offered to come to the next appointment. Damian said he would ask if he needed company. Martin did not insist. At the gate, he turned back and said he would prefer an uncertain truth to a comforting story. Damian considered the sentence after the car had gone. He suspected Martin was trying to give himself courage as much as advice. He put the yellow coat back in its box but left the drawing of the ship on the desk, where it could be a drawing again.
Damian was about to say that not knowing had become the argument with which he dismissed every chance he had missed. But Martin was not dismissing the chance. He was separating it from certainty. Together they copied the notebook's dates into a new timeline. Where the original record contradicted a later document, they drew a narrow red line in the margin. They made no attempt to decide what the contradiction meant. By the time Martin left, there were eleven questions on the list and not a single answer Damian could present as proof.
That night he dreamt of the reception centre. In the dream every door led back to the same desk, where an exhausted volunteer kept asking him to spell Iris's name. He woke before dawn and found the page of questions on his bedside table, where he had carried it without remembering. He put it in the folder in the sitting room. For once he resisted making another call at five in the morning. The people who might answer were not hiding the truth by sleeping, and waiting until office hours did not mean he loved Iris less.
He went out for a walk while the roads were nearly empty. At the corner bakery he bought two rolls, although he wanted only one. When he came home he put the spare in the freezer. The action struck him as absurdly hopeful, the smallest possible preparation for another day. He made coffee and began a letter asking for copies of the consolidated patient-transfer list. He checked each date against Martin's notebook. He wrote the sentence ‘I am seeking clarification, not asking you to assume an identity’ and left it in. It sounded like something Esther might say, and it was true.
A week later Martin called after reading a news item about an old disaster review. He wanted to know whether Damian had seen it. Damian had. The article described administrative mistakes in another region, not Bellwater, and suggested that digital records created long after disasters could reproduce mistakes in paper originals. They discussed it for five minutes. Then Martin asked if Damian wanted to come with him to watch a football match on Saturday. Damian almost refused because he felt it would be frivolous to sit through a game while the review was unfinished. Then he realised the investigation could take months. He agreed to go.